On Stablecoins and System Integrity

There has been increasing discussion around the utility of dollar-backed stablecoins within decentralized systems. While these instruments are marketed as a means to facilitate adoption and bridge to legacy finance, they introduce several structural issues that compromise the foundational principles of peer-to-peer electronic cash.

First, stablecoins rely on centralized custodians. This is fundamentally at odds with a trust minimized system. Any asset that can be frozen or reversed by a third party is subject to the same limitations as traditional banking. It inherits the risks of regulatory capture, counterparty failure, and censorship, nullifying the advantages of decentralized networks.

Second, pegging value to fiat currencies such as the US dollar effectively ties the system back to inflationary monetary policies. One of the primary motivations for Bitcoin was to create a currency with predictable issuance and resistance to arbitrary monetary expansion. Stablecoins maintain dependency on fiat, and therefore, do not solve the problem. They recreate it on a new platform.

Third, widespread reliance on stablecoins introduces systemic risk. If a significant portion of activity is denominated in assets that require off-chain guarantees, any failure of the issuer could result in loss of funds or network disruption. These are single points of failure, which decentralized systems aim to eliminate.

Ultimately, stablecoins do not reduce trust! They shift it from governments to corporations. In practice, this can lead to greater surveillance and control over user funds, particularly when used at scale.

The goal should not be to replicate the legacy financial system with new tools, but to create an alternative that is inherently resistant to control, self-sovereign, and secure by design. Stability may be desirable, but it should not come at the cost of decentralization.

Systems that rely on trust will always be vulnerable. Decentralization only works when trust is minimized through code, not reintroduced through custodians.