It depends what your threat model looks like, I’ll lay out two scenarios:

1. You want to buy bitcoin but you don’t want to correlate that purchase to you as a person at all. This is a scenario where you want to achive the highest amount of privacy where no one knows that you own that particular set of UTXOs(or any bitcoin at all).

2. You don’t care if other third parties, such as governments or exchange employees etc, knows that you own bitcoin but you don’t want them to know which UTXO you own. They know you owned the UTXO you bought on the KYCed exchange but you’re able to hide through CJs, on-chain/LN swapping etc.

I don’t think there is a right or wrong that fits everyone here so you have to figure out what fits you and your own life situation. I tend to think that scenario 1 is the one to aim for but it is more expensive so you have to figure out if it’s worth it to ensure your ultimate privacy or not. It’s also a bit harder than scenario 2 because most offers in the no-kyc market are requesting payment through KYCd payment rails.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

I agree - there is no right or wrong. Those two scenarios indeed seem to how we should assess our priorities. Also - what could governments even feasibly do against millions of people holding bitcoin that is inherently unconfiscatable? They know you have it, but can't take it. 🤔

Green tax on bitcoin holdings... They know you had it at some point. Itd be a tough spot. Suddenly you're a criminal and much of the public would be on side.

if they ever did this would seriously consider leaving the country. not just bc of the tax implications but also bc of the authoritarian implications.

Oh they can absolutely take it. If someone knows where you live and knows you own bitcoin, what’s to stop them from breaking in and torturing you until you give them access to your privatekey? The asymmetric cryptography makes it unconfiscatable as long as you can keep your privatekey a secret. The “$5 wrench attack” has happened so many times that Lopp has a overview of all known physical attacks on bitcoiners:

https://github.com/jlopp/physical-bitcoin-attacks/blob/master/README.md

Funny side note: I had an argument with a random account on Twitter a while back where he insisted that this was no problem for him because he knew Jiu-jitsu (or something similar) so he could just beat up any cop that tried to take his sats😂 I wish I could find that thread for you guys but it’s #NostrNovember so no can do.

what happened to that Loaded character is scary. gov just threw him in a cell till he gave them the key.

I guess humans will do whatever it takes...