“Paying off my mortgage gives me peace of mind.”

Sounds smart, right?

It’s actually one of the most expensive emotional decisions you can make.

Here’s why paying off your mortgage early makes you poorer (and less free).

A 30-year fixed mortgage isn’t a ball and chain.

It’s one of the best financial tools available:

✅ Fixed terms for decades

✅ Predictable payment

✅ Inflation eats away at its real cost

Time and debasement work in your favor.

Prepaying your mortgage locks up capital in bricks.

That kills:

❌ Growth

❌ Flexibility

❌ Freedom

And for what? A feeling.

Let’s look at the math.

Have $100K?

Option 1: Pay mortgage at 5% “return”

Option 2: S&P 500 (~10% historical)

Option 3: Bitcoin (conservative 20%)

After 10 years:

🏠 $163K

📈 $259K

₿ $619K

“Peace of mind” could cost you $500K!

And it gets worse:

Broad money supply (M2) grew 7% annually over the last decade.

Your “guaranteed” 5% return is actually a -2% real loss after inflation.

“But it makes me feel safe.” Nope.

You’re trading one risk for another:

✅ Less debt

❌ Less liquidity

Need cash? You can’t peel off a piece of siding.

You’ll refinance or sell...often at the worst time.

Smart money = options.

Keep the mortgage.

Invest the difference.

That gives you:

✅ Bigger portfolio that compounds

✅ Liquid reserves to cover mortgage if life happens

More liquid assets = more security.

FIRE + bitcoin is about freedom and optionality.

You don’t get that by locking up cash for your feels.

You get it by keeping your wealth working and outpacing debt.

Poorer isn’t safer.

This week’s FIRE BTC issue breaks down the full math and mindset shift:

👉 Why “peace of mind” is a costly illusion

👉 Why a mortgage is your friend

👉 How to build security without killing flexibility

Read the full post + subscribe here: https://firebtc.substack.com/p/peace-of-mind

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Still a MASSIVE liability. Emotional indeed.

Rent, down payment in Bitcoin instead is far more profitable. Houses are shitcoins. An inferior money. Also, no Great Taking risk from a mortgage.

🫡

You can’t pull off a piece of siding for money, but you can always refinance or do a HELOC.

HELOC is great but typically much higher, variable rate and is callable

I’d be careful with the ideal that you can “always” do that. You should have a more liquid emergency fund available. Trouble tends to bunch up. In 2008-09 lots of people lost jobs, and not many banks were willing to lend them either.

Fair point. I don’t have my house fully paid off. Just including some nuance. You can access capital when your house is paid off.

The S&P doesn't even beat real inflation experienced in most US cities.

https://chapwoodindex.com/

US real estate doesn't beat the real inflation of any US city.

You're better off stacking gold than paying off real estate early.

This is my argument for normies. I don't need to tell people on nostr they can do better than gold. They already know that.

Early 2020 i took a new job and moved across the country, bought a house and used a 20% downpayment to avoid mortgage insurance. Dumb move, should have paid minimum down and bought bitcoin. Made up for it by taking a HELOC in mid 2022 to buy bitcoin which is now worth 60% of the value of the home. I think in s couple of years the bitcoin will be worth more than the home.

Damn, legend!

Thanks for this take. I have been trying to get the balance right on this one. I keep feeling frustrated with mortgage debt, seeing it as a massive obstacle. Good to hear a researched opinion on why I don't need to pay it off now.

Appreciate that! Imagine if you COULD pay it off at any time, but you don't have to

you dont know what you are talking about.

Thank you for this really helpful comment 😂😅