If you read the original conversation the challenge had nothing to do with it. Never denied any of the claims Super was making about Lightning or Monero.

I just don't think that you as the sender knowing the amount you're sending (duh) to the stealth address that you created (duh) is the dunk that some think it is.

In the real world, if an adversary (like the authorites) are undercover as a sender, they aren't going to care that technically the invoice doesn't show your public node. They're going to arrest you because you were the one who gave them the invoice/address they paid. At that point, using Monero/Lightning won't matter, the only thing that would protect you would be remaining anonymous from the start.

By the way, did you want to join the follow pack?