Libertarianism today just means statist-lite; which frankly gives one the worse aspects of statism. In many ways it is like an inversion of the concept of minarchism.
If one truly believes in the principles of traditional classical liberalism, they will inevitably end up as an anarchist, as the state simply cannot respect individual rights or their autonomy.
I think it’s more multi-dimensional than that.
Some people want small government but recognize the state for basic order, eg minarchist. Others advocate for small government but then suddenly jump ship into big government if it comes in the way they want it.
I think that last part of what you said rings true. As soon as some people feel like, "well if the government is enforcing stuff along my cultural lines then it's okay" - when they should resist the urge to give them such authority - even if it plays in their favor
Libertarianism today are just people rooting for the Mexican Invasion of United States.
One Race Human Race ! We all bleed red ! Borders be staytis an shiet !
For many being a libertarian today is akin to claiming to be an independent or not voting down the ticket. One sees the nastiness of the blues and reds and socially doesnt want to be seen that way. Even though, when it comes time to vote or take action, they make the "lesser of evils" argument and go with with big govt.
It all starts with rules without rulers. And must be protected so it stays that way by the same group of individuals with the same moral values respecting freedom over (sense of) security.
No elite, no monopoly on violence, no "healthcare" facade, real education, respect for personal property, free market capitalism to name a few. And yes, we will build the roads.
