So… what’s our fix for community posts being kind 1 notes - showing up out of context in feeds?
Asking for a friend.
Discussion
A new kind, there's a PR out now
I know it’s a big ask … and I’m a nostr nobody… but I really think so many event kinds (only for user generated content) will unnecessarily contribute to NIP bloat. And why should new content types be locked behind a NIP approval process anyway?
As a Kind 1 event, this problem could be solved simply by adding a ‘c’ tag. It is a perfect use case for
Look like we can detect if the post is community post or not by look a tags. If yes, render the community information. I will try implement it in Lume
What about titles?
I see that as a feature not a bug.
As that is seeing someone you followed posting into a community.
That's a feature, not a bug. Otherwise you can be censored by the community mods
Communities are moderated so that doesn’t really matter
It absolutely does. Right now, precisely they are regular kind-1 notes, your followers still see it in their feeda even if the community moderators disapprove the note. They just won't show up in the community feed/note list.
its totally out of context, no title, doesn't reference anything, even if your followers see it, what's the point? it's just a note then. Post a note instead.
Notes in general are like that though, they're really not different.
This is the same discussion, I am trying to have at resolvr, it all makes no sense without context.