Replying to Avatar Disturbia

i tried the cake wallet to try out monero

the first thing turned me off was the 25 words backup phrazs.

the second thing that turned me off is the confusing backup system.

so this begs me to ask : between monero & zcash, which is a better privacy tech and why
Avatar
Saberhagen The Nameless 2y ago

In isolation, shielded Zcash sender privacy is technically better than Monero, but that is all. Example:

Monero:

6% Alice sent $[?] to [?]

Zcash:

[?] sent $[?] to [?]

But this small advantage is overshadowed by many other problems that I showed you in that link.

Some big ones:

Optional privacy - Very few users to hide among.

No layered privacy like Monero - if privacy breaks everything is potentially exposed

IP not hidden by default - what good is privacy if your transaction is accidentally linked to your IP?

Dev tax - lmao

Has known devs, a CEO, and a corporation - easy targets for manipulation and state force and regulation.

and much more...

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Avatar
Saberhagen The Nameless 2y ago

With the Seraphis upgrade coming down the road Monero sender privacy will be just as good as Zcash using full membership proofs without all of Zcash downsides.

Ring signatures have never lead to anyone being discovered or busted in practice. They have been robust enough. 1 in 16 chance of guessing sender correctly. And with every hop it is 1 in 16^x chance (x being number of additional transactions).

Chance of correctly guessing sender after 3 hops:

6% -> 0.4% -> 0.02%

The amounts and recievers are still completely hidden.