I will.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

What concerns me is that by circulating a 'list' of relays we inadvertently centralize relays and that would be bad.

WeAreSoEarly.gif

That's what clients already do when they come with a list of recommended relays.

That said I believe this is how it's supposed to work. If you want to see my content, you at least subscribe to read access to the relays I use and if you want to comment you have to have write access.

Well, maybe not all of them, but at least one of them. Right?

I think so but we are entering into territory that I don't think anyone fully understands. I say this because network theory (at least what I know from biology) is insanely hard to comprehend.

Fuck it! I'm all in AF!

More than your final list, I would love to see a description of your criteria and methodology for determining the best relays. (If you’re up for it :)

Oh wow you have 28 relays lmao

i know..... im baaaad. 

I had about 15 relays ~1week ago and was experiencing poor performance on several clients. Ppl recommended I pair down to 5-8 relays, and things have been great since. Caveat:

1 week in Nostr == 1 month in Bitcoin == 1 year in Earthtime

I had 37 relays last week, so i've gotten rid of some of them :P

First step is admitting it

ty sir. you get me.

Gm! What’s your criteria and process to pick and choose relays?

My methodology will be based on relays on different continents, ping times, popular relays, default relays used by clients, relays used by popular users, relays used by certain people I follow. I'd like to get down to 12 and and see how that goes. I'm sure a lot of relays will tick a lot of these boxes too. Maybe I'll make a spreadsheet. People love spreadsheets!

Sick. Spreadsheet would be a good start. As we refine and weight these metrics, I could see relay ranking systems emerge similar to Lightning router rankings

I don't know if this will be super scientific, but I will try my best to use the categories or methods I mentioned earlier.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1HmHZNaGyrGZlI_y-d21vOeqKyo08dAY4WXZaTa5yTFo/edit?usp=sharing

Seems like a great starting point. I am a data analyst, lmk if I can help at all

Could you check on our Kenya relay too?

wss://nostr-1.nbo.angani.co

Followed.

I'm thinking that for every 3 "solid" relays we should include one wimpy ass "outlier" so that one gets connected AF and becomes kinda beefy.

Or am I just not understanding this at all?

right, we probably should not all just load up on popular relays, it may be best to spread the love and actually decentralize instead of recreating a small centralized network.