How do you access/manage all these alternative relays in the most straightforward manner?

👉 with a key pair

So you might as well have used that from the get go and avoid all the complexity.

With just relays:

- you move the problem to the relay

- are still very dependent on your relay service provider

- have worse (non-Nostr) identifiers

...

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Keypairs do not already function like groups. Relays do, which unlocks progressive enhancement — one part of which is adding a keypair so it can publish notes on its own behalf.

Keys do not make good groups, believe me, I tried it: https://github.com/nostr-protocol/nips/pull/706

You can already fetch all kind 1s on a relay.

You can already fetch all kind 1s targeted at an npub (on their inbox relays).

Both can function like a community.

Both are currently not used like that.

Only the latter gives me what I need.

Until you want to enforce access control or moderation, then you're in rube goldberg land

For reliable access control and moderation, you need your own relay.

I love those incentives.

How do you manage that relay? 👉 With a key pair.

How do create multiple groups on that same relay, without having the NIP-29 mess? 👉 With key pairs.

How can you try out groups/communities without having to run a relay? 👉 With a key pair.

Or MLS, which granted is hard to implement, but fits this problem like a T

Yes, MLS may yet save us from this madness