You might wanna read Harry Halpin's analysis. Knowing Harry quite well, he isnt right on everything, but he does have some good experience.
Discussion
Thank you
Ridiculously overboard "it has no privacy". AFAICT he's saying there's a failure vector, and a very big one. Then 'bitcoin/lightning has NO privacy', that's ridiculous in context (well, especially, small one-off payments on LN).
TLDR valid points overwhelmed by hyperbole.
I mean he is building a competing thing, which is really cool but also insanely slow.
He’s not technically wrong, but two hop is still way better and more performant than his idealized solution.
Someone should also ask Harry how preminig a token is improving the privacy and security model of the Nym network.