Why does #[0] call home to ajax.googleapis.com before I even sign into the app?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Probably google analytics

What a horrible thing to implement in a #Nostr client.

nostr:note1vmgj55sqrg5lcf42hpcg4emqtltcg3sflmxppn8qvp4yycpkjnqspd3az5

It could be any one of a list of JS toolkits that they might have used being pulled down using Google as a CDN, or it could be a form of app analytics.

https://developers.google.com/speed/libraries

Very disappointing.

Tbf, I have been concerned about this with a number of clients. Allowing YouTube embeds is just as bad from a tracking perspective. It would be good to convert YouTube links to invidious embeds instead.

Do you know other clients doing this as well? Which ones?

I don’t know of any specifically using Google Analytics, but several PWA clients have external embeds on by default. Some allow you to turn them off.

Iris has this under Settings->Content

I’m not sure how this works on Snort, Coracle, et al.

+1 for Iris!

nostr:note1vmgj55sqrg5lcf42hpcg4emqtltcg3sflmxppn8qvp4yycpkjnqspd3az5

They should completely de Google the app

💯 yes. And have it available on F-Droid.

Report is wrong unfortunately.

No matter what it is, the fact is Nostr should not be calling on Google APIs for anything. Disappointing. What's up with this nostr:npub1plstrz6dhu8q4fq0e4rjpxe2fxe5x87y2w6xpm70gh9qh5tt66kqkgkx8j ?

🤔

🤭

Tokio is irresistible.

Hi, we use open-source privacy focused analytics called Plausible that helps us improving Plebstr.

We self-host them on our Google Cloud and that’s why you can see this.

We don’t use Google Analytics and we don’t collect any user-linked data.

Analytics by design are not privacy friendly. Open source does not = private. Do you have plans to remove this in the future. Will Plebstr be available on F-Droid without analytics in the future?

I asked dev fren about this, cause it sounds bit off putting, but I’m not sure that it is, he said:

They’re even self hosting it, so plebstr is the only ones who have this info, and it’s very little info. Tbh I would not be surprised if TestFlight collects more info than this by default.

I dont want plebstr to have ANY info. Also I completely avoid testflight because its cancer.

Also said:

It’s all aggregated data - like which feature is used most - not individual.

The fact that Google is involved in hosting any sort of data is concerning.

nostr:note1vmgj55sqrg5lcf42hpcg4emqtltcg3sflmxppn8qvp4yycpkjnqspd3az5