Replying to Avatar walker

This is a really great point by nostr:npub1gcxzte5zlkncx26j68ez60fzkvtkm9e0vrwdcvsjakxf9mu9qewqlfnj5z about community.

People go to BlueSky because they want a “safe” community of leftists (politicians, journalists, celebrities, and normal people) who all agree with each other and think X is for Nazis and Elon is the antichrist. On Bluesky, their views will not be challenged, because they are the same as everyone else’s. They do not need to worry about being confronted with uncomfortable truths. There is “diversity,” but no diversity.

People go to Threads because they want a “safe” community of leftists (politicians, journalists, celebrities, and normal people) who all agree with each other and think X is for Nazis and Elon is the antichrist. On Threads, their views will not be challenged, because they are the same as everyone else’s. They do not need to worry about being confronted with uncomfortable truths. There is “diversity,” but no diversity.

People go to [INSERT NOSTR CLIENT] because they know it an “unsafe” community of people who cannot be defined by a single political label, comprised of plebs, technologists, dissidents, legit cypherpunks, anarchists, entrepreneurs, Bitcoiners, open-source devs, artists, podcasters, creators, activists, and more.

On Nostr, people expect to be challenged, because there are no guardrails. They expect to encounter views that clash with their own. They expect to be uncomfortable at times.

Nostr enables confrontational truth (paraphrasing nostr:npub1l2vyh47mk2p0qlsku7hg0vn29faehy9hy34ygaclpn66ukqp3afqutajft )

There is “diversity,” but there is also diversity. nostr:note152609lgkamcey5kq5qka6y4023kh7cxxvg54gkn0hpndm6k0cfzsjcta3z

Not everyone cares about politics though. And that's where I understand the need for "safe" community. And nostr experiences are currently lacking in this direction.

Imagine I'm an older lady* that's really interested in beautiful crochet and hand made stuff, I would like to have experience where other people show off their crochet, we have fun, we can joke and help each other.

Since I have many stresses, worries and other issues in my daily life and I get my news from elsewhere I would just like this place for my fun time, for my rest, for calming down.

Now what is the chance that people start trolling (preying on escalated discussions), people call each other nazi/commie, I'll get exposed to politics, people explaining their virtues, trump, conflicts, biden, videos of murders, linux developers, scammers, porn, ukraine, etc.

If the chance of me being exposed to garbage (we can call it *P(shitshow)*) is larger than lets say 10%, then the fundamental reason for me participating in that community (=app) disappears.

One interesting side effect of this is that there are many (MANY!) great niche communities that use super old websites/forums software (powered by things like phpBB), because younglings usually don't find it slick/new enough, so quickly lose interest.

*) I'm not saying crochet is only for older ladies, I'm saying that this specific crochet aficionado happens to be an older lady in the situation I just made up.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

No replies yet.