First, let's not put words in my mouth. 👍

Second, filtering types of data is objectively removing a feature. Filters are objectively negative things. Not in the "oh my feelings way", they often have positive effects, but they are negative features.

Often times, removing features is a good thing. Especially if it is unused, broken or unwanted.

Since this is not a consensus change, it should be noted that we have time to evaluate the damage and reverse it. We can all switch to knots or do something else if it has negative effects.

I know it's not that simple, but when shit is hitting the fan, that's when people get serious.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Removing a feature from the mempool policy (Removing the ability for them to set parameters on the OP_RETURN) is not the same as a node runner applying a filter. These 2 examples are not comparable one is removing the ability to set a limit, the other example is applying a limit.

Agreed. Didn't realise you were talking about that.

Yes, I agree that removing this optionality, especially when people are using it, is bad.