Originally, it meant war to save Islam. Only the prophet and his successors, which is what caliphe means in arabic, could call for it. And it is considered as the most guaranteed way to paradise. “Jihad fi sabil Allah” is the full expression and it translates to “struggle towards god”. Many caliphes called for it. What comes to mind is Saladin at the end of his reign, to remove the last remnants of the crusader states.

The last official call for jihad was by the last ottoman sultan in ww1.

The interpretation as an “internal struggle” came as an attempt to reform the concept of “jihad”, hoping to shift the mindset of muslims from external war against others, to internal war against sin. But it hasn’t succeeded, and since there isn’t any official reference for religious authority in islam, like what we have in the Pope as Catholics, any sheikh can just be his own reference and interpret “jihad” however he sees fit.

“Internal war” when it’s beneficial to appear peaceful, and “external war” when in a position of strength for example

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

yes, only the kaliph can and must periodically call offensive jihad on infidels, until the whole world is muslim. And the ottoman sultan was also the last kaliph. Obviously, it's not always possible to wage large wars, so he can run small expeditions to capture slaves/loot, etc, or persecute internal non-muslim minorities, to save face following the letter of the law.

as there is no kaliph, smaller governments must defend the muslim territory they are responsible for - permanent peace which permanently yields their territory to non-muslims is not allowed. And they can call for defensive jihads to defend the umma (all muslims), against attacking infidels.

this explains why bin laden always framed his fights as defense against neo-colonialism, cultural influence, or previous invasions - he knows he lacks the authority to wage offensive jihad with no provocation.

and why egypt could make peace but hamas or fatah can not: egypt surrendered the responsability over Gaza to the PLO.

also, why, if Israel gets weak, muslim countries can claim to be defending the umma, and declare war again.

And why previously muslim lands are always remembered first as targets, such as Spain or India.