Depends on what you mean by legitimate. In a philosophic Thomas Paine way then no it is not a government made up of the "will" of the people.

But look around the world, there are lots of governments that run with sham voting or no voting at all. They are legitimate governments that that legitimately hang you in the city square.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Who does the hanging?

A government can be given power, or extract it via violence. Either way there are humans behind every expression of "legitimacy".

Its always humans who give a government power. True, humans with guns can instill a lot of "legitimacy", and disproportionally so.

I have no interest in "giving" a government or anyone else power over me or anyone else.