You can't do chargebacks with ecash. It also has better privacy properties than lightning.

Ecash has better UX, as you said, because the overhead of maintaining a lightning node is offloaded to the custodian, who can be compensated in the form of fees.

Is this the value for value everybody keeps talking about? Liquidity management, uptime, and privacy provided in exchange for transaction fees. Seems like a good trade to me b/c I don't want to do all of that work just to zap shitposts.

Which is it? Brittle and complex or better UX? You can't take both sides of the argument.

Not sure why you are accusing me of being a shitcoiner. Do you have a rational line of reasoning or is this just plain old ad hominem?