Does frequently going in and out of #Monero create privacy threatening meta data?

I ask because I see it touted as a privacy solution against #Bitcoin. Say I buy that (I'm not educated enough on the topic to have much of an opinion either way except to say I don't think it's any less private). I'm not leaving my wealth there, so I'm going to bounce in and out of it if I use it (like I do with fiat now). Is the privacy any better that way? Or would I just need to write off an amount to leave in the ecosystem?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

i guess in that case, it becomes as private as the exchanges used 🤔

If done correctly I would say it's even better than a coinjoin (swap p2p back to Bitcoin in different amounts and at different times)

An adversary surveilling Bitcoin wouldn't even necessarily know you left the chain. They just see your Bitcoin move to another address like normal. Coinjoins are obviously coinjoins.

This is the way. More easy to maintain. Treat Monero as your spending account and Bitcoin as your saving account.

For generational wealth I'd recommend going at least 50:50 as you don't want to doxx your future family.

Addressing my previous comment, if you're going to go that route, I do think it's better privacy-wise to have a small stash of Monero that you use directly to pay for things and just top up every once in awhile as needed. For a small amount, and short-term spending, the price performance is negligible. At those shorter time scales Monero outperforms Bitcoin all the time, so it's anyones guess. You'll probably break even if you're always doing it.

Yes, it is harder to maintain privacy that way because you create plenty of metadata that might be unique.

With FCMP++ in October the Monero side gets its most important upgrade in half a decade, that helps protect the Monero side of things even better, which is probably the reason we currently see the media campaign/state attack through qubic.

Exchanges are your weakspot.

Use something like RetoSwap or Eigenwallet (atomic swaps) over Tor that do not report your IP to authorities.

What does all that matter if they bought kYC Bitcoin to convert to monero.

I never said it did. Or that they did. I'm interested in either assumption if it makes a difference.

You need to exchange some for Monero and just leave it because going in and out as a chain hop is not going to help you be any more private.