You honestly don't think the reply to this highlight is something I would like to see on my amethyst feed given that I follow you??
Discussion
I do, but only because Amethyst supports Highlights, the root kind.
If Amethyst didn't display the root kind, you would just see a bunch of replies without context (or needing to use another app to get context)
And that is just a terrible experience.
NIP 89, 31 my man
NIP-31!!!
Imagine if the template your app creates even generates a gorgeous card for the NIP-31 opengraph and your not-9802-supporting-client just renders that.
Context was the missing piece to make this work and NIP-31, specially with the template idea, provides all the context, and with NIP-89, you can even find how to consume the unsupported content (i.e. if it's a podcast open fountain, etc)
I think this is more or less what I had in mind
It would enable a far more interesting internet with more niche use cases
nostr:naddr1qvzqqqr4gupzp75cf0tahv5z7plpdeaws7ex52nmnwgtwfr2g3m37r844evqrr6jqy88wumn8ghj7mn0wvhxcmmv9uqpqvecd96nvar5de4nv7nhxdmkgeqfea8mz
Sure, but why can't you do NIP-31 with Comments themselves? If the answer is NIP-31, you can just NIP-31 everything, including Comments.
hmmm, because they wouldn't be rendered? because they are a different kind? we're talking in circles but I think now on the github issue we've arrived to a conclusion