I had not heard of #[0] until they announced they were posting on #nostr

I welcome varied news souces with various perspectives

Reading about Jacques Ellul's classic book from the 1950s about technology and "Propaganda", at the moment

According to his definition propaganda and misinformation are different things. IMHO, Ellul and McLuhan were two great thinkers ahead of their time

It would be nice if one day that nostr was a tool to minimize propaganda and maximize the utility of news feeds. Not an easy task by any means!

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

The difference between propaganda, advertising, spam, and actual news is a subjective value judgement — and even the objective distinction between factual and false information can only be evaluated subjectively.

I don’t think a protocol per se can disincentivize propaganda — and I don’t think it’s possible to design a protocol around that goal.

However, any protocol that maximizes subjective value in general can be used to reduce propaganda— if “propaganda” is something people don’t value and they can identify.

I don’t think Nostr is such a system right now — at least not more than other platforms — but maybe it will become one.

I think a first step in limiting the power of propaganda is to eliminate the disparity of power between information gatekeepers and recipients. At the end of the day everything is in the eye of the beholder and nobody's perfect, but with equal reach for everyone the incentive to lie declines because you can be called out anytime anywhere and everyone can see it.

Edward Bernays. Powerful. Uncle Sam, bacon & eggs, women smoking, etc etc.

It's called "freedom torches," not women smoking ;)

You’ve obv been brainwashed I see ;). Freedom torches for all.

I love Elull's book La Technique, he literally invented the term "Fake News" in it.

We're not claiming to stop propaganda per se. But what we are trying to do is to level the playing field so that all sources can be heard.

That in itself would be a huge step to attenuating the force of propaganda coming from centralized sources.

Thanks for the support!