Testing jumble.social – If I post with jumble while looking at a certain relay set. Does it post only to that relay set?
Discussion
Hi nostr:nprofile1qqsgzfdez8ksa9xmuvqg5zly3nl9e5xqkpvj8nllj9aw06ra4pqq3qcpz4mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuerpd46hxtnfduhsz9nhwden5te0dehhxarj94ex2mrp0yhxzurs9uqsuamnwvaz7tmwdaejumr0dshstm459s I have spent a bit of time using Jumble today. I love it and wanted to give some feedback.
In Relay settings > Relay sets it took me a while to work out what "Push to relays" and "Pull from relays" meant. I understand now that it means "Save" and "Load" the relay sets to the network as a kind 30002 note (so I can load them in another browser).
In Relay settings > Read and Write Relays it was unclear if editing this would change my settings globally for other clients, or just in relation to relay sets (I had to delete some things to check, and then re-add them).
What I was hoping for was a solution where I can select a relay set and then both read and write only from that set.
Perhaps when posting a note on Jumble I could have the option to post only to the relay set, or to post to global relays.
I imagine—
- Creating a relay with read and write auth using NIP-42 for a small team,
- Using Jumble with that relay for that team,
- The team uses Jumble primarily to post notes for each other, but
- Whenever they want they can choose to post a note globally, to share with the world.
Thank you for your appreciation and feedback!
> If I post with jumble while looking at a certain relay set. Does it post only to that relay set?
Jumble will send your notes to the write relays you have configured and the relay set currently in use. For replies, likes, etc., they will also be sent to the read relays of the mentioned users.
> In Relay settings > Read and Write Relays it was unclear if editing this would change my settings globally for other clients, or just in relation to relay sets (I had to delete some things to check, and then re-add them).
It will modify the kind 10002 event, which may affect other clients that also use the kind 10002 event.
> Perhaps when posting a note on Jumble I could have the option to post only to the relay set, or to post to global relays.
I would be happy to add this option. As for replies, they might still need to be sent to the read relays of the mentioned users, otherwise, they might not see your replies.
That would be truly great.
- if relay set is selected,
- when posting, default post to relay set (and replies) only (rather than global),
- could add NIP-70 tag to (in theory) limit propogation to other relays.
I should be able to pair this up with a relay with NIP-42 read and write for a very good simple community UX!
I think this direction is worth exploring