You don't seem to understand what is censorship and how it works.

1. The basic sociology proves you wrong. They don't need to follow that list per se. They follow as default behaviour of ignorance. The mainstream relays/clients they choose (path of least resistance) work as default blocklist. Majority of users will stick with default for ignorance.

2. I said it on second day using nostr, it was obvious that claim "censorship-resistant" is oxymoron. Censorship is social behavioral problem, not protocol problem.

It's not one evil entity censoring all the victims. It's most of the victims that agree with being censored. Every aspect of censorship is communism. So if the majority of population's thinking is communist nothing protocol can solve.

It's more or less same as on fediverse. There is no free speech if everyone is communist like Eugen. There is only free speech because of the Volk behind The Great Wall of Marxtodon.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Basic sociology proves me wrong but you seem to agree with me that users wouldn't care to change the defaults and follow a block list by themselves. On the other hand I would trust sociology any more than astrology either to be hones.

And yes, as I wrote I'm not sure about the relays. Or clients for that matter. If it is possible for them to collude and ban wrongthink as the default then it will probably happen.

Here is how it's supposed to work:

https://nostr.guide/nostr-protocol-for-a-censorship-free-social-network/

"On Nostr, a user can be blocked from publishing on a specific relay, but they can still publish on other relays and maintain their identity and follower base. To make it easier for users to find new relays, the client software can automatically add recommendations for new relays to the list of relays it queries whenever someone you are following posts a recommendation.

If a user wants to migrate to a new relay, they can publish a recommendation to their previous relay and move their data. If a user is banned from many relays and cannot broadcast their own recommendations, they can still let their close friends know which relay they are publishing on through other means, and these friends can publish recommendations to the new relay. This process can help the banned user’s old follower base find their posts again through the new relay. The same process applies if a relay ceases operations."

I don't know how this works practically though. How can I post a relay recommendation? Do clients implement this feature? Anyway the fedi will stress-test the censorship resistance of the network for good and we are going to find out soon :p

Yeah it's all nonsense right now.

This is the future of Nostr here:

https://mastodon.social/tags/fediblock