Replying to Avatar Thayr

It is connected to other works and is considered a part of a series demolishing the idol of Muawiya (who demolished the caliphate and tens of thousands of companions and even more regular Muslims to establish monarchy that its effects are oppressing us to this day monarchy after monarchy and dictatorship after another as if it's OK or islamic, etc)

Samura was an enforcer for for Ziyad brother of Muawiyah who was installed governor in Basra and Kufa in Iraq by Muawiya and hr approved of Samura and his actions of mass murder of Muslims and any who dared to return the caliphate or at least get shura back as in their authority in their lands i consultation. (BTW alhasan albasry was known to believe whoever narrated to him). This small research book opens with authenticating(rigorously) the hadith of the Prophet pbuh by Abu Hurairah : That the Prophet, peace be upon him, said to ten of his companions in a house, "The last of you to die will be in the fire". In them is the brow of a soldier. And that , " Samra was the last of them to die . "

And that this hadith was definitely said by Abu Hurairah (by eight different source narrations as in the Narration has 7 other affirming narrations) and he was absolutely terrified that he would be the last to die and it be applied on him.

Samura even sold alcohol not caring about it being haram and a cursed thing to do so when Caliph Omar heard of it he said May God Fight Samura (which is the title of the research)

https://sunnah.com/muslim:1582a .

(This is just a tiny bit of the research)

TL;DR

Purpose of the work – Part of a larger series that seeks to dismantle the mythologized image of Muʿāwiyah ibn Abī Ṣufyān, whose establishment of hereditary monarchy shattered the original‑consultative (shūrā) model of the early caliphate and set off a chain of dynastic oppression that still haunts the Muslim world.

Key figure: Samura bn Junb – a ruthless enforcer appointed by Ziyād ibn Muʿāwiyah (Muʿāwiyah’s brother) when Muʿāwiyah placed Ziyād as governor of Basra and Kufa.

Samura led mass killings of Muslims who resisted the new monarchical order or tried to restore shūrā.

He openly dealt in ḥarām liquor; when Caliph ʿUmar ibn Al‑Khaṭṭāb learned of this, he reportedly prayed, “May God fight Samura!” (recorded in Muslim 1582a).

Hadith focus: The author rigorously authenticates a prophetic statement transmitted by Abū Hurayrah:

“The last of you to die will be in the fire.”

The narration includes ten companions gathered in a house; among them is a soldier (Samura). The hadith is supported by eight independent chains (seven additional corroborating reports), establishing its soundness (ṣaḥīḥ) that Abu Hurairah definitely narrated it and more.

Abū Hurayrah himself feared being that “last” and the prophecy was later applied specifically to Samura, who indeed became “the last of them to die.”

Overall argument: By proving the authenticity of the hadith and documenting Samura’s brutal actions under Muʿāwiyah’s regime, the research shows how the early caliphate’s ideals were subverted by a nascent monarchy. It frames Samura as a concrete example of the tyranny inaugurated by Muʿāwiyah—an oppression that has been repeated through successive monarchies and dictatorships, falsely presented as Islamic. The work therefore contributes to the broader project of exposing and rejecting that legacy.

I think this is a red herring regarding Islamic revival. I don't see how demolishing the Muawiya idol would achieve that. I think that most nonsectarian Muslims would agree that Muawiya was the فئة الباغية، and they have a fairly good understanding of how fairness & justice should look like in a Muslim state.

Putting all this effort to undo what Muawiya did, seems to me like a huge effort for nothing. As if Muslims already dont instinctively understand that our leaders today are our butchers. They don't need someone to draw a direct line between our leaders and the disastrous effects Muawiya's coup.

I'd rather look forward. i.e educate ourselves on how Sharia can be applied in today's world, educating ourselves on the disastrous effect of not applying it.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Problem is most Muslims are sectarian and can't get away from what Muawiya enshrined as islam :

Monarchy/Governance of whoever wins power, Dictatorship, Sacred Companions that you can build rulings from even if contradictory to the Qur'an or Prophet pbuh and ruining reason when you accept everyone's narration about the Prophet pbuh even if they're mass murdering liars who don't care about Islam that would demolish Islam itself so how do you solve that?

And why is there no Islamic governance like the Prophetic model or even Rashidun Caliphate for millennia?

There are hadiths about this that have been hidden (not talked about and sometimes falsely weakened) like the hadith about that first of islam that goes away is governance and the last is prayer, another hadith is the first and last of my ummah is its best and what's between is muddy, another hadith is: most of my nation's hypocrites are its scholars, another hadith is: ''Be upright to Quraysh (the rulers) as long as they're to you, but if they're not put your swords on your shoulders then eradicate them but if you don't then you'll be suffering croppers eating from your hard labor'' btw prophet pbuh saying quraysh here is just based on him knowing that arabs will only choose quraysh people at his time and that obviously has changed just as people change in every time and people's moods change and it doesn't allow the understanding of quraysh as the only allowed rulers because there are other hadiths like the one of: “Even if the one appointed over you is a mutilated Ethiopian slave whose nose and ears have been cut off, listen to him and obey, so long as he leads you according to the Book of Allah.” ( https://sunnah.com/ibnmajah:2861 ) and the verses of shura that contradict this understanding because consultation is amongst the believers.

I advise please to read at least the works about Monarchy being kufr as in not islamic governance, the fundamentals of rulings and if you can the main book which is called Tawheed (because it uses it to refute Wahhabism and establishes Foundations about islam and reasoning, etc) there are other books that would be very beneficial and we can discuss. The works is backed by Qur'an and heavily researched verified hadiths, narrations, etc so it's not empty or useless it is bringing forth understanding of Islam based on the Prophetic model and proving it and disproving big hurdles like fake contradictory hadiths and schools of thought in "Islam" that have plagued Muslims into following the Judeo-Christian /Caesa-Khosrow ways of Churches and Scholarly Sacredness and Hierarchy and obedience to the tyrants and making a lot halal things haram and making halal things haram but basically everything is ok for the people in power because to uprise is supposedly fitna even though fitna is actually being oppressed and not being able to apply Islam and have your complete rights.

Abu Sa'id al-Khudri reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying:

You would tread the same path as was trodden by those before you inch by inch and step by step so much so that if they had entered into the hole of the lizard, you would follow them in this also. We said: Allah's Messenger, do you mean Jews and Christians (by your words)" those before you"? He said: Who else (than those two religious groups)?

https://sunnah.com/muslim:2669a

A different narration talks about following in the ways of Caesar and Khosrow (Monarchy /Dictatorship)

Also what about the hadiths about Muawiya being the Pharaoh of this Ummah, and the Prophet pbuh said it in a non direct way he said it is between Muawiya and Abu Dharr and we know Abu Dhar didn't have anything near governance or anything problematic like being a mass murdering tyrant who tried to silence any hadiths and allowed the flow of whatever he liked and whatever he said as truth then being enhrined as a sacred idol in the Umayyad dynasty and even beyond being the main reason of monarchy /dictatorshipand if you say anything about him you're effectively an enemy of any state that is like that in the Islamic world throughout history.

The research proving/authenticating this hadith:

https://t.me/mo2allafaty/32