I once heard someone say ā€œgod is the blanket that we throw over the mystery of the universeā€ and that really stuck. Yes, we don’t, we can’t, understand the universe, but we need some way to process it, some way to deal with the uncontrollable nature of it, and so we call it ā€˜god’.

I read a book on happiness once that told a story about a young couple who had lost a child. They were religious and took great comfort in the idea that this was ā€œall a part of god’s planā€. I have very mixed feelings about that. We can examine the seeming cruelty of ā€˜god’ in that situation, but we can also appreciate that they found a way to come to grips with the lack of safety in the world, and the uncontrollable nature of our universe.

ā€˜God’, or religion, really does give a lot of peace of mind to a lot of people in crisis. The concept is a hack for learning to "let go." But there are down sides. No one wants to be a passenger in car when the driver says ā€œJesus take the wheel!ā€

And this is just such a constant wrestling match in my head. How do you be a responsible person, how do you keep planning for the future while knowing, while holding the knowledge that you live in a universe without safety? A universe that you can’t control, where tragedy is always possible. How the fuck do you do that?!?!

I do have some idea. I know that planning is entirely necessary in this life, and so you gotta keep doing it. And also, you have to hold the reality that there is some percentage, some amount of the situation that is, from our perspective, totally random and uncontrollable. I am now capable of intellectually acknowledging that, and I’ve been learning to decouple tragedy with shame or guilt, or even failure, in my thought processes. But I haven’t found a way to emotionally hold this reality.

Ideas?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Following many years as a rabid atheist, I began exploring, learning about, and employing buddhist practices, not as a religion, but as a framework and a set of tools with which to wrestle with these seemingly insurmountable challenges.

Nothing compares to "doing the work," (meditation, mindfulness), but of the dozens of books I devoured on the subject, this was perhaps the most profound for me.

I, am as you. An atheist, though I do have an interest in Buddhism for the same reasons as you. I too, have read a good number of books on the subject but not this one. Thanks for sharing.

Now on my kindlešŸ™šŸ».

Some degree of ā€œblindā€ belief seems necessary to our agency. I use quotes because I don’t think it’s actually blind in the religious or even intellectual context. But it does involve a degree of faith.

I have models that afford me agency in the world. I’m not entirely sure these models are correct, but they allow me a movement in the world. So I trust and have faith in them. Because without them I’m stagnant.

I also considered myself an atheist for many years and scoffed at the idea of faith. But I have a different understanding of it now.

Faith allows us to step forward when we’re really not sure where our foot will land.

Faith doesn’t have to be religious. I have faith in relationships and my framing of the world, but that doesn’t mean they won’t change or evolve. Faith is not rigid.

Not sure if that was helpful or not but those are the ramblings that your post provoked out of me. That and the two cups of cold brew coffee I’ve had.

GM

For me, it was verify, don’t trust.

I grew up being told that Christianity was the truth, and had a difficult time trying to find ways to squeeze objective truths (dinosaurs, the age of the Earth, where the other people came from that Adam & Eve’s kids married, etc).

After understanding that the Creation story was drafted by people who clearly did not have omniscient knowledge of history, it led to understanding many other aspects of the religion were created by humans for their own motivations, and then to realizing all of it is.

Removing the ā€˜problem’ of the inconsistencies of religion makes life simpler.

It was difficult for me bc everyone else in the family/community/whatever still believed in the truth as told by the Bible. But letting go of it bc it cannot objectively be true undoubtedly later helped me to question the reality of our financial situation and why ₿ is so important. The ā€˜leaders’ in my financial community/family were telling that this system based on trust is the way to go forward, but objectively, the system based on math and physics is obviously going to win. Honestly it surprises me when I encounter so many Bitcoiners that are still devoutly religious. But, everyone is on their own journey, and it generally is not harmful for people to believe in a religion that allows them to take the weight off their mind. (Caveat: Some religions/subsects of religions are harmful to others.)

TLDR; try to let go of the religious guilt that you are saddling yourself with. The universe is random, and everyone in it is looking out for their own interests.

"try to let go of the religious guilt that you are saddling yourself with." is this about you? Is it directed at me? I ask because I didn't directly mention religious guilt in my post but quite a lot of it was installed in the back of my head when I was young and I'm still trying to remove it. I'm curious if that came through in my post.

Yes, it was about me, but directed at you, because you were mentioning the guilt. I referenced the bitcoin because to me there is an analogy with regards to ā€˜everyone’ believing in the old system, but after you discover the old system is wrong, you don’t need to be burdened by the belief set (guilt) of bad system.

I really like the way Jeff Booth frames this in the sense of not solving the problems of the old system within the framework of the old system. The new system/paradigm fixes the problems. And also how he talks about wanting to help bring the new system to fruition so he moved his time and energy into the new system.