Some common opinions I disagree with:

* "Everyone should have a NIP-05": Most people aren't associated with a domain and shouldn't have a NIP-05. Being associated with a domain you are not associated with is pointless.

* "The Twitter Algorithm hooks people": I don't believe the Twitter Algorithm has anything to do with why we get addited to social media. I'm addicted to nostr. It's a human instinct to keep up to date on what is happening in your social group.

* "Long posts are annoying/bad": While I think long posts benefit from subject lines or brief summaries at the top TL;DRs, I think it's up to clients to make long posts less annoying. If you want to write a book chapter as a TextNote, I think that should be fine and clients need a way to handle that (e.g. click for more).

I'm sure I have a lot more less-common opinions, but these were just now floating around in my head so I thought I'd write them down.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

🤝

I've complained about your first point countless times.

If someone is not associated with a domain, their NIP-05 is pointless to me and tells me nothing (other than they maybe paid a few cents over LN once, but that's what paid relays are for).

I don't want to be that negative but a lot of those services kinda just rided the hypewave for a cash grab.

I watched it. I still disbelieve. It's a constructed argument, well painted, but IMHO not really based on good evidence.

Don't make me open my conspiracy theories memes folder 🙄

I hold all the conspiracies in superposition. Any of them might or might not be true. Being in possession of very few actual facts, the only stories I can confidently rule out are ones that excessively violate general principles I've learned... like flat Earth.

Far to many people rule out the mainstream story because they feel it violates some general principle they have learned, but usually they are just less likely, not ruled out.

For example, it is quite possible that Jeffrey Epstein killed himself. It's hard to know when someone is suicidal. Prisons are often run incompetently .. incompetence is truly widespread. But it also very much fits the facts that some powerful people wanted him dead, disabled the cameras, paid off the guards. I don't have the facts necessary to decide, and I bet you don't either.

Another example, I think the US blew up Nordstream 2 with or without help from an ally with 95%+ probability, and I thought this before the Seymour Hersh story. In fact I was pretty adamant that any social media influencer or podcaster or youtube personality that blamed it on Russia was either incredibly stupid or is perhaps a paid asset of the CIA. I know some who are not stupid, so I now suspect them of being CIA assets, and I pay much less attention to them now.

Agree on the three points but specifically on the first:

I've being warning for some time that NIP-05 has been oversold as "user verification" dangerously by some clients and services.

I'm very "pro subject line", I use it to keep a devlog.

I have a lot to say on this matter, and my followers are probably tired about me talking about it in posts & replies but will keep it brief until we have “read more” in more clients.

Clients doing different things with \"display_name\" and \"name\" is annoying.

I think this is all to avoid the valid mastodon criticism that @jack@cash.app looks like an email to both humans and operating systems, so we are desperate avoiding using double @‘s to compete with did/atproto in a much simpler manor.

if that wasn’t a valid critique most clients would just have a bold display name for your full spaced name or nick name, and use nip 05 as a unique handle in all situations.