Anarchy without private property and free-market is just a mess and chaos
Discussion
Georgism ftw
Georgism isn't against private property, it just differ the degree of use and occupancy from others theories of property
It's not private if you can't use it at your will.
In a voluntary decentralized contractual community it's acceptable
I'd like to see how that voluntary decentralized contractual community looks like, where land use isn't private.
Where's this located? Is can I join?
Georgism advocates land tax. How do members of the community earn to pay this tax? Do they have skills and trade?
I think different models of property can co-exist as long as they're all voluntary (in a communal level). If you want to enjoy absolute property rights you'll have to live isolated like a hermit
Absolute property rights are what people here are advocating for. If you think a different sort of community can exist you'd actually have to show me one.
Absolute property rights and absolute freedom of speech doesn't exist if you live in a community. The difference between a libertarian and a statist in this assumption is just how they negotiate these rights, libertarians negotiate in a voluntary contractual level and statist leave these decisions to the government bureaucrats
Just to complement my prior comment, Kevin Carson made a good point how these different theories of property could coexist in an anarchist society:
" Imagine an anarcho-capitalist community (Rothbardville) based on non-Proviso Lockean rules. An individual appeals to the community’s protection agency to enforce her property claim in a neighboring community which holds to the Ingalls-Tucker occupancy-and-use property rules, and collect rent from an occupant who refuses to recognize her title to the property. Given the enormous cost of enforcing such a claim in a community which regards it as repugnant, the anarcho-capitalist protection agency would likely have an exclusionary clause for such claims, or require the payment of an additional premium that would exceed the rental value of the property. In the mutualist community of Proudhonia, the mutual defense association would likely have a similar exclusionary clause for owner-occupants seeking protection from self-styled landlords in the anarcho-cap community. "
Private property is the base of civilization