I will have to translate your tweet but ofcourse, if anyone actually got fired from their job for mistaking someone’s pronouns I would be opposed vehemently. I just was familiar with the panic in Canada around C-16 that to my knowledge has never actually happened. We should oppose all forms of inhumane rules and regulations that don’t take nuance into account.
Discussion
not only get fired, you know. being canceled is totally against what we used to preach as well, butler was completely against cancel culture, she abhorred it. cuz it’s the typical thing that oppressors do. I don’t wanna be an oppressor. 🥴
Wasn’t butler all about discourse? That undermines that entirely. I think that in cancel culture in the form of mass reporting and outrage comes from a form of slave morality that we should be quick to call out.
look for her "Excitable Speech", it’s all there. totally against it. an excerpt poorly translated: "Stating that certain utterances are always offensive, regardless of context, that carry their contexts with them in ways that are difficult to describe, yet it is not understanding how context is invoked at the moment of utterance". there are more incisive parts I’m not finding rn. but while I agree with you I really don’t see it being called out, not until it’s too late and we’re totally enslaved. that’s the plan. as I’ve written during the pandemic: who is going to fight against control (of the state, of power etc.) if those who used to fight it now are the ones who demand it?
try to translate this article by a friend of mine, lygia maria, we used to protest together when we were kids, now she’s considered an alt-right by brazilian left and most of our friends quit talking to her, she’s columnist of folha de sp (which would make ME stop talking to her, lol) and hated by both sides: https://www.facebook.com/100006566658355/posts/pfbid0arYTpazSwzzXFM2hRUFphG2rEoapq6hb7M2LbzjtxLqsE3JsCXFAaWu2TbYuVXewl/?mibextid=Nif5oz
brazilian left had the audacity to cancel MBEMBE, I mean… wtf is wrong with these people?
"if anyone actually got fired from their job for mistaking someone’s pronouns I would be opposed vehemently ... that to my knowledge has never actually happened"
You didn't look far.
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/peter-vlaming-transgender-student-lawsuit_n_5d9600bce4b02911e116d773
https://nypost.com/2022/10/28/coach-travis-allen-suspended-for-misgendering-trans-student/
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2023/may/19/indiana-counselor-sues-after-being-fired-over-crit/
That’s not accidentally misgendering that’s just refusing to gender correctly. For decades it was an insult to call a cis-man a “women, girl, sissy, etc.” That’s because it’s straight up disrespectful. And to do that to your students? God no.
Nope. It is refusing to gender INcorrectly.
You know what is disrespectful? Pretending to be something you're not, and then getting people who are actually the thing you're pretending to be fired from their jobs, censored and cancelled for calling you out on your lie.
Besides, calling a man a girl is disrespectful not because he's not a girl. It's disrespectful TO WOMEN because you are implying that women are weak and useless. Your new variety of far-left sexism is just as bad as it ever was when we were told to stay in the kitchen - arguably even worse, because now you're locking us up in there with entitled autogynephiles and pedophiles.
I see this isn’t going anywhere and have a good day. It must be fun holding such strong beliefs about people that don’t actually impact your life in any way.