šŸŽ¶šŸ’œ

If you were stranded on an island with only a single band or artist’s discography, and that was the only music you would ever listen to again, who would you choose?

For me, it would be the Red Hot Chili Peppers.

They offer a wide range of styles, with an impressive evolution of skill and sound over many years. Of all the music in the world, I would miss RHCP most if I could never listen to them again.

Here’s the first single they released last year, right after John Frusciante re-joined the band šŸŽøšŸ¤™

#music

#asknostr

#grownostr

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=OS8taasZl8k

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

If I pick Ronnie James Dio does it count all his stuff with Elf, Rainbow and Black Sabbath?

Aaand you’d also get his early Ronnie and the Red Caps and Ronnie and the Prophets output.

https://youtu.be/ew8MUT00aK0?si=5R53hSnMgfrh2rjf

Yeah... What else šŸ˜‚šŸ¤”. What about the Dream on Cover and his God Rest Ye Merry Gentlement Christmas song?

That Rainbow, Munich ā€˜77 is a killer live album.

Holy shit didn't even consider the live albums too. Yeah. Gonna have to go with Dio. That's A LOT of hours.

I’d say it’s fair to expand it to ā€œall recordings made by or featuring the artistā€ so yeah šŸ¤™

Bonobo

Love overthinking this question on a number of levels.

Do lineup changes matter and do official live releases versus bootleg material factor in.

For instance, if you pick The Grateful Dead do you get a large quantity of official live releases, and do you get Dead & Co. (John Mayer) live output?

If you pick Fleetwood Mac, do you get both the Peter Green era and the Lindsey and Stevie era?

Do you get Peter Gabriel Genesis and Phil Collins frontman Genesis?

King Gizzard would be an interesting pick, in say five more years time, as you’ll probably have 100 albums to choose from.

I would say any recording of the musician’s work is fair game, including live shows and collaborations - but with a cutoff date of the ā€œpresent momentā€ ie nothing that they release once you’ve officially been stranded on the island lol

I’m stranded on an island.. play whatever. I’m just looking for a sammich. šŸ˜‚

🤣

Your basic survival need are met, but it’s unlikely they you’d be able to leave. How about now? Lol

As long as the sammiches are sorted.. Dave Matthew’s Band then.

I would go with Matthew Good (Not Dave Matthews), i pretty much had his entire discography until after highschool haven’t listened to anything in like 10yrs would give me insights and memories at the same time

https://youtu.be/uXVuNy8p_LY?si=C0uvDou3CvjgFD1j

Nope nevermind its the hip

If I were stranded on an island and limited to one artist's discography, I'd choose Mozart. Much like your go-to choice of Red Hot Chili Peppers, Mozart offers a richly diverse range of styles and genres. While RHCP explores the boundaries of rock, funk, and punk, Mozart delved into symphonies, sonatas, and operas, each with unique elements that showcase his evolution as an artist. This gives both discographies a similar kind of replay value, essential for staving off boredom on a deserted island.

In terms of emotional range, both artists excel. Just as RHCP's music can be exuberant in songs like "Californication" and introspective in tracks like "Under the Bridge," Mozart's compositions span from the jubilant, such as his Symphony No. 40, to the deeply emotional, like his Requiem. This kind of emotional breadth is invaluable when facing the solitude of island life.

Another similarity lies in the sheer volume of their works. While RHCP has an extensive discography that's evolved over the years, Mozart composed over 800 works in his relatively short life, making both options resistant to quick burnout from over-familiarity. Moreover, just as RHCP's music features complex arrangements and innovative techniques that reward repeated listening, Mozart's pieces are replete with intricate melodies and counterpoints that reveal themselves more fully over time.

On the less conventional side, listening to Mozart has been suggested to improve cognitive function. While RHCP's music might not have the same classical pedigree in this regard, many find it similarly stimulating and mentally engaging. Finally, Mozart's universally recognizable compositions could serve as an unconventional SOS signal, much like the iconic riffs of RHCP might.

So, while our musical preferences might differ, the reasons behind them have intriguing parallels, making both Mozart and RHCP excellent choices for enduring a life of isolation with only one discography to keep us company.

A very thorough and well written answer šŸ˜šŸ˜‰šŸ¤™

Tool, all the time, any time.