Replying to Avatar Lyn Alden

Too many people have given Elon a pass. Don't give him a pass.

He's a marketer, not a founder or an engineer. He didn't found PayPal or Tesla; he bought into them early. He's good at selling narratives and equity valuation for perpetually unprofitable companies.

Everything for him is a narrative. His green revolution was a narrative to sell more cars and get more subsidies. His bitcoin purchase was to gain appeal among bitcoin/crypto people in a bull market. And he shilled doge like a dumbass. His SpaceX narrative is to get money from the government.

His rooftop solar thing was an outright scam; the technology isn't ready and went nowhere because of that. His full-self-driving-in-an-intermediate-term timeline was a scam, and is going nowhere because of that. He makes scams to draw people and capital in, because for him it's all about narratives and equity valuation.

And then he dug unproductive holes, suggested unproductive hyper-tubes, built meme flamethrowers, for what? It's a narrative, not a business. None of this is real productive shit to make peoples' lives better.

His latest "we need free speech" narrative was a scam too. He tapped into something real, which is what marketers do and why it kind of worked. Yes, we need free speech. Yes, Twitter had censorship issues. He saw that and jumped on it maliciously rather than productively.

But what did he replace it with? He replaced it with arbitrary journalist censorship about his private jet, arbitrary censorship of Substack, selective Twitter Files release, won't talk seriously about any of his China connections because Xi Jinping fucking owns him economically there like Jack Ma, has his balls firmly in his grasp, etc.

Elon's playing the narrative, the anti-woke meme of the day. He's a master meme-momentum-player. Don't fall for it.

Agreed wrt Twitter.

As for all his companies being a scam... I think the evidence suggests otherwise.

Tesla sells the best EVs on the market. Objectively that's a fact, they've been ahead of the game for over a decade - but yes, the constant promises of FSD "soon" were erroneous.

SpaceX has the NASA contract because they make better rockets than their competition. There's multiple videos and livestreams of SpaceX reusable rockets not only successfully launching but also the thrusters landing on small targets in the middle of the sea. Reusable rockets are a big deal.

SpaceX is also behind Starlink which is expensive, yes, because it's new technology, but it works. Speedtest data shows that in many countries it's faster than normal broadband on average.

Elon was a co-founder of PayPal and Tesla, and the sole founder and chief engineer of SpaceX.

Don't get me wrong, many of your criticisms are perfectly valid. He is very good at using his memelord status as a marketing tool. He is not totally honest and has his own agendas (he is after all a CEO). I'd also add to this and say he's often immature (Thai diver drama) and doesn't always think things through (Twitter purchase).

And of course he puts on a persona for PR reasons to keep his fanboys happy. Recently he tweeted against the WEF calling it an unelected world government (which is true) but a few weeks later he was at the World Government Summit which has such a strong overlap with the WEF that Klaus Schwab himself was a keynote speaker.

I have no strong feelings about Elon myself and my distrust of him has only been growing recently. I don't trust a word he says about politics and world events. Like you say it's all just a narrative.

But saying he's simply a con artist whose companies have no merit at all just isn't supported by the evidence.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

No replies yet.