I think the Q1 is more of a luxury because of the QWERTY keyboard. I would buy it if it's available and the price isn't a problem. Maybe it will have a longer supported life. The Mk4 is my most trusted option. SeedSigner is good but it doesn't store your seed. Jade was kind of buggy with Green but it works.
Discussion
Wow - great assessments and info, very much appreciated.
Q1 seems highly experimental with new features, and I don’t exactly need all the bells and whistles necessarily that come with it. I’m almost certain I wouldn’t use half the features, but the batteries and keyboard are tempting for convenience.
SeedSigner and MK4 were really the ones that were 50/50. MK4 seems like the most frictionless option when it comes to security + ease of use - which is ultimately what I’m looking for in a HW device.
Jade I’ve heard too many mixed things on that create some concern.