Replying to Avatar Seeker Erebus

You really don't get it. You are not going to convince any long time student of bitcoin to be interested in Monero, ever, no matter what. There is no improvement you can make, no advancement, no marketing campaign, absolutely nothing. This is not because of the infamous bitcoin immune response, mind you. It is because of a fundamental law of nature that a longtime student of bitcoin has a grasp of that you are either unaware or willfully ignorant of.

Bitcoin discovered, for the first time, a way to create absolute scarcity. It's arguably as important a discovery as the number zero. Most importantly, it can only be done ONCE. BTC is the token that represents that absolute scarcity. Whenever a separate token has been created, from LTC, to XMR, to ETH, to all the rest, they are incapable of being anything other than a fiat expansion against BTC, and violate the absolute scarcity of BTC merely by existing.

Were the developers of Monero to finally accept this fact, and put their engineering skill to work improving bitcoin instead, I'm certain the privacy we all need could be implemented. Instead, we fight, you lose, and maybe we all suffer far longer than necessary because the one money that can actually do the job wasn't given necessary upgrades.

BTW, There is a trick you can do that would allow a new chain to be created without being a fiat expansion. Establish a fixed ratio of BTC to the token, and permanently burn BTC on-chain at that ratio each time. If the ratio is never broken, then you've transmuted BTC and conserved the absolute scarcity. I have zero idea what the market would do with that, mind. And there are other pitfalls that can befall any such project. But the discovered law would not be violated, and it might be the only way to implement a hard-fork level upgrade to bitcoin that could actually work, should that ever be necessary.

Stop making some weird appeal to "longtime student of bitcoin"

It means nothing. Just because you've been a "student of Bitcoin" doesn't mean you don't have blindspots or can't be retarded.

"it can only be done ONCE"

Tell the darknet markets that. Bitcoin had first mover advantage AND network effect. Didn't matter. Monero still took over on the only truly free markets that exist and only place where permissionless transactions are possible.

"absolute scarcity" doesn't automatically mean anything. Value is a function of supply AND DEMAND. Bitcoiner *should* know by now that value is subjective and the market is constantly reevaluating. Value is not fixed just because scarcity is.

https://github.com/libbitcoin/libbitcoin-system/wiki/Scarcity-Fallacy

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

🤨