Pretty much every claim that says “you could run your own… x y z” or “you can spin up your own …” is total nonsense. This is not how people use anything. Only the highly technical devs might do that but your average person will not fork any app or code base or run their own instance of any server .. on localhost 🤣 c’mon… get real.

Either it’s so easy everyone can do it, or it’s centralized.

Nostr has a lot going for it where a client dying off is not a big deal if other good client options exist. Can’t say the same for other protocols. But, we need multiple client options on multiple platforms at all times.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

You said it 😄. I am a person with zero knowledge code base

This is why I insist so strongly that Nostr relays have to be absolutely dumb. Only like that we can keep having third parties with the required technical knowledge running them incurring as little potential legal liability as possible, so normal users don't have to run their own relays (which they will never do).

You could run your own car 😂

Why does that have to do with nostr?

Its the level of complexity that you can expect most to do

You have to take driving lessons and practice. Not sure if that’s a good comparison.

People will do it they get something like that in return. Ability to go places comfortably with little hassle (especially in places with bad transportation options). If they would need to host stuff locally to run a car they would 😂 so what is it that users would want with similar benefit out of nostr?

Also very different levels of motivation. One is necessary to get to places to do the things you need to do, other is a shitposting platform 😂

Ross was unique, he learnt it and done it from scratch.

💯 it’s hard enough to convince people to buy a cold wallet, nearly impossible to convince them to running their own node.

Everything needs to become plug & play and the UX needs to be on „apple-level“, otherwise all of this nice technologies will just be adopted by the nerds…

It's a continuum, not a binary choice between decentralised or not.

I appreciate the option to run my own instance as a step in the right direction.

Ultimately, of course, the goal should be full decentralization, which does require sufficient ease of use.