Are you 100% sure about this. Can you do me a favor and open a new browser window, where you are not logged into Primal, and go to this URL: https://primal.net/e/note1pcl7nvl77za6ksl3evquzlvmau4czenw73m07n55tdszv4n24gvqka2jdt .. for me no matter what browser I try it in, I don't see any replies by nostr:npub1kun5628raxpm7usdkj62z2337hr77f3ryrg9cf0vjpyf4jvk9r9smv3lhe ... you say you ahzve to "click a particular reply" ... can you confirm that when you use this link, and do this, that you see your own notes? I can't find them!!
Discussion
Which client was this note posted from?
Yakihonne.
I think this is a Primal issue. I don't use normally Primal, but from I understand Primal doesn't deliver notes to users by pulling from author's outbox relays. It goes through their cache servers. But when you publish a note, it does go to the relays you have configured which are your outbox relays. I wasn't able to see Dikaios's replies on the web browser, or in the Primal app. But I was able to see them in Amethyst and Yaki. So, I'm thinking there's something crappy going on with the Primal caching system because it's the only client with this unorthodox system for pulling notes, and it's the only client that isn't properly showing all replies.
This is correct about how Primal works. Users are only ever reading from Primal's caching server, and writing to their outbox relays. However, my notes and replies are showing fine on Primal, even on a completely separate web browser and without being logged in, so Primal's caching server has my notes. See my reply here:
Alright, I have done the above. From that link, opened in a completely separate browser with no NIP-07 extension, so I was logged out the entire time, I just had to do the following:
Click on nostr:npub10mtatsat7ph6rsq0w8u8npt8d86x4jfr2nqjnvld2439q6f8ugqq0x27hf's reply, click on your next reply, then click on nostr:npub13thhtj384uq2dacvzjr94efgvrxdcd50geyecl8kkg6jkzd8p86sgtwvcs's reply. And there I am:
nostr:npub12vkcxr0luzwp8e673v29eqjhrr7p9vqq8asav85swaepclllj09sylpugg please fix this madness. There is no way that the optimal behavior is to hide all the notes in a thread unless you manually click on exactly the right reply? 99.99% of users will not be expecting this behavior….