pretty sure nostr band significantly underreports user numbers

nostr:nprofile1qqsrx4k7vxeev3unrn5ty9qt9w4cxlsgzrqw752mh6fduqjgqs9chhgpremhxue69uhkummnw3ez6ur4vgh8wetvd3hhyer9wghxuet59uqsuamnwvaz7tmwdaejumr0dshspqtwny thoughts?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

What user numbers specifically?

Found nostr band always had trouble accurately calculating zaps

the site is currently reporting less than 20k active users, that is way off

How do you figure? Is there another source?

i appreciate the project, and brugeman alot. but yeah. the numbers are off. at least for follows and zaps sent.

not sure it’s possible to get accurate numbers though because of the nature of the protocol

Everyone knows there's actually 24 active user (blokes) on nostr

the best 24 blokes in the world so we got that going for us

Just verified myself

Yes seems to be off. Showing ~same numbers as 18 months ago

These are "trusted users" - those with non-zero trust rank that we use to filter spam. You can turn-on raw numbers if you want, but those are meaningless and fluctuate wildly. I don't think anyone else even attempted to calculate some sane numbers that filter out bots, so there's nothing to compare to. We published our raw event data sets a while ago, if anyone wants to run their own numbers, I'd be happy to see an alternative view.

Keep those numbers below reality. The less they think people use Nostr, the less they'll try to take it out.

Once Nostr takes off they will seize nodes, ban IPs, etc., in the name of false narratives like hate speech, domestic terrorism, insurrectionists, anti-semite, or whatever anti free speech nonsense they manage to come up with.

No global feed seriously limits the freedom of reach.

Nostr over Meshtastic, there's some hope there.

Count matters far less than trend

i think the trend is off too lol

Primal probably has the best data!

I don't think we underreport. Why do you think so?

Is there another resource for these metrics?

not that I am aware but maybe there should be

Tbh, comparing here to Farcaster, it looks pretty accurate to me.

I'm mostly reader. There are probably more like me

does nostrband count mostrpub users as nostr users

yes