Nostr Web Client

Replying to nobody

It is not that simple. You can make a strong case that if the US had not murdered 100k civilians in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the Japanese would not have surrendered, which would have necessitated a ground war in Japan for the Allies to win the war, that would have no doubt resulted in the death of millions of Japanese citizens.

Mr. Fred Rogers 2y ago 💬 3

I believe it IS that simple nostr:npub1ul45aruuhu09e5nts8mn49wsvhu58q8qmpvyyvpa0qhuvljehnys4uyt0r . I have a worldview/religion that says that murdering people is always wrong.

Making theoretical death calculations is not my job. I’m not God.

Example, I could theorize that a daycare down the road is housing a future mass murderer. A few parents are super jacked up and are training their kids to kill.

I cannot go kill all those children because I calculate that it will likely save more lives in the long run. I don’t know the future and I have no green light to kill.

Honest question: where is your moral principle that gives you the right to kill innocent people? Do you subscribe to a religion that says this is okay?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

CensorThis 2y ago

Your arguments are nonsense.

nobody 2y ago 💬 2

So if you had the chance to murder Adolph Hitler in 1939 knowing his plans for the destruction of Europe/Russia and mass murder of the Jews, and you knew the likelihood of him being able to do it, you wouldn’t murder Hitler because you don’t know the future for sure and your worldview/religion that says murdering people is “always” wrong?

CensorThis 2y ago 💬 1

Not really worth it.

Their replies have been incoherent, emotional, and illogical for the most part.

They’d prefer to rewrite history from a seat 100 years away than to face the harsh realities of the day.

nobody 2y ago

Exactly, not worth it.

Mr. Fred Rogers 2y ago 💬 2

This hypothetical is ridiculous because humans can’t know the future, like who Hitler would become. That’s one of the main points why murdering people for better future outcomes is evil. If someone killed your child because they thought he would turn out bad, I have a feeling you wouldn’t shrug it off. Furthermore, the US didn’t just bomb Hitler, they bombed a bunch of innocent people along with some “bad guys”.

Why is this hard for you? Are you on team USA no matter what? Are you afraid of meeting your maker and therefore willing to murder to stay alive longer? I’m seriously asking.

CensorThis 2y ago

Your hypotheticals so far have been literally retarded.

There’s no point in having a discussion with sub 80iq such as yourself.

You can’t see how absurd your points are.

For example, in this hypothetical you contradict yourself.

So dumb.

Mr. Fred Rogers 2y ago 💬 1

Ps I love seeing “note from a user you muted” and moving on without clicking. Refreshing.

CensorThis 2y ago

Yet you continue to reply

Sub 80iq.

Luke Dashjr 2y ago 💬 1

Are you saying you would???

CensorThis 2y ago

It’s a bullshit hypothetical.

No answer here matters.

Quit trying to rewrite history.