I'm building currently using ipfs ... looking at using arweave

I remain curious to see how the transition turns out 🤙

Have they solved problems though? I feel like the odysee people wouldn't do that since they seem to support censorship

Architecture Notebook: Nosternity (Notes and Stuff for Eternity)

#nostr #aeternity #arweave for #eternity

---

Overview

Nosternity-Arweave integrates Nostr, Aeternity, and Arweave to create a fully decentralized, scalable, and censorship-resistant platform for communication and data storage. By leveraging Nostr's protocol, Aeternity's blockchain for identity, payments, and governance, and Arweave for permanent, immutable storage, the platform ensures secure, verifiable, and cost-efficient communication and content storage.

---

Core Principles

1. Censorship Resistance:

Nostr relays, Aeternity's blockchain, and Arweave’s permanent storage ensure a robust, distributed architecture with no central points of failure.

2. User Sovereignty:

Users control their keys, identities, and data.

3. Scalable Payments:

Aeternity’s state channels enable scalable and low-cost micropayments.

4. Permanent Storage:

Arweave ensures that critical content and notes are stored permanently and immutably.

5. Decentralized Governance:

Smart contracts on Aeternity manage platform governance and relay rules.

---

Key Components

1. Identity Layer

Technology: AENS (Aeternity Naming System).

Purpose:

Provide decentralized, human-readable names tied to cryptographic public keys.

Integration:

Arweave transactions reference AENS identities for provenance and verification of stored content.

---

2. Relay Layer

Technology: Nostr relays.

Purpose:

Store and propagate lightweight messages off-chain.

Integration:

Relays interact with Arweave for permanent storage of important notes.

Relays validate user identities through AENS.

---

3. Storage Layer

Technology: Arweave (Permaweb).

Purpose:

Provide permanent, tamper-proof storage for important notes and data.

Features:

Critical messages are uploaded to Arweave for long-term accessibility.

Stored data includes hashes for on-chain verification on Aeternity.

Metadata (e.g., timestamps, author identity) is recorded alongside the content.

---

4. Blockchain Layer

Technology: Aeternity blockchain.

Purpose:

Manage payments, governance, and key anchoring.

Features:

Incentivization: Users and relays are rewarded with AE tokens or custom AEX9 tokens.

Data Anchoring: Arweave storage references are hashed and recorded on Aeternity for verification.

Governance: Relay policies, fees, and user inclusion/exclusion are governed via smart contracts.

---

5. Payments and Incentives

Technology: Aeternity state channels.

Purpose:

Enable scalable, low-cost micropayments for:

Relay usage.

Storage fees on Arweave.

Tips and rewards for content creators.

Workflow:

Users pay relays and Arweave storage nodes directly via state channels.

---

System Workflow

1. User Registration and Identity Management

Users generate cryptographic keys and register with AENS for a human-readable name (e.g., steven.chain).

AENS identities are referenced in all Nostr messages and Arweave storage transactions for verifiability.

2. Message Propagation and Relay Interaction

Users send signed messages (notes) to Nostr relays.

Relays propagate the messages across the network.

For critical messages, relays initiate storage on Arweave.

3. Data Storage on Arweave

Important notes or large content (e.g., images, documents) are permanently stored on Arweave.

The Arweave transaction includes:

The note content.

Metadata: Timestamp, author’s AENS identity, and Nostr relay reference.

The transaction hash is recorded on the Aeternity blockchain for tamper-proof verification.

4. Payments and Incentives

Users pay for:

Relay usage (propagation fees).

Permanent Arweave storage (calculated based on data size).

Payments are facilitated using Aeternity state channels for scalability.

Relays and Arweave nodes are rewarded with AE tokens or AEX9 tokens.

5. Governance

Relay inclusion/exclusion rules, fee structures, and platform updates are managed via Aeternity smart contracts.

Community voting ensures decentralized governance.

---

Advantages of Nosternity-Arweave

1. Permanent Storage:

Critical notes and content are stored immutably on Arweave, ensuring long-term accessibility and resistance to data loss.

2. Censorship Resistance:

Nostr relays, combined with Aeternity and Arweave, create a multi-layered architecture that prevents central control or data suppression.

3. Scalability:

Aeternity’s state channels enable fast and low-cost transactions, even at high usage levels.

4. User-Friendly Identity:

AENS provides a seamless way to manage cryptographic identities.

5. Incentivized Ecosystem:

AE tokens reward relays, storage providers, and content creators, fostering a sustainable ecosystem.

6. Verifiable Content:

Blockchain anchoring ensures the integrity and provenance of stored data.

---

Challenges

1. Complexity:

Integrating three decentralized technologies (Nostr, Aeternity, Arweave) requires careful design and coordination.

2. Cost:

While Arweave storage is cost-effective for long-term use, upfront fees might deter casual users.

3. Adoption:

Relays and users need to adopt Aeternity and Arweave for the system to work effectively.

4. Scalability of Arweave:

Arweave nodes must handle increased storage demands as the platform grows.

---

Future Enhancements

1. Cross-Chain Interoperability:

Integrate with other blockchains (e.g., Bitcoin, Ethereum) for broader adoption.

2. Content Indexing and Search:

Build a decentralized search engine for Arweave-stored notes.

3. Enhanced Privacy:

Incorporate encryption for private messages and sensitive data.

4. Mobile Integration:

Develop lightweight mobile clients for easier access and usage.

5. AI-Assisted Governance:

Use AI to monitor and assist with relay governance and content moderation.

---

Conclusion

Nosternity-Arweave represents a powerful convergence of Nostr's decentralized messaging protocol, Aeternity's blockchain capabilities, and Arweave’s permanent storage. This integrated architecture offers a scalable, censorship-resistant platform for secure communication and content storage, paving the way for a decentralized future where users own their data and identities.

I hear odysee is adopting arweave but before that's done they'll probably take away my account for having no valid email address

Test: Hello #ArFam @npub1gn9mppOar20k5zayxurclvkqnur8nvc9mwmhOuv3qefsm30fspns2fffv2

chads are

It’s 2 am, my feed is all in Japanese. But here are some conceptual ideas of what is #nostr. The last one is my favorite.

⚠️ Not your keys 🔐 not your #bitcoin 🗝️🔑

while I agree it would be good to have more content to explain nostr, it won't really matter given the current onboarding and product experience. it's way too confusing for folks, and generally not satisfying instantly. people will and do churn out.

if there's one thing to focus on (for the social media use case) it's search. both for people, but more importantly, topics. Twitter won because of search. it wasn't a social network. it was an information network, and it excelled at real-time because of real-time search. that's a base requirement now.

what nostr adds, and what will make it sticky, is the multi-app/use-case ecosystem. but each use case is going to have different needs for attracting people to it. search is table stakes for the social media one. it won't matter how good the tutorial content is until this is done right.

nostr has the benefit right now of having a completely open and wild API. that matters as every other service is closing down. it's perfectly OK that we mostly have devs and bitcoin-obsessives at the moment. we have time to get all the kinks out and make something that's truly hard to replicate. where the only way to compete will be to join.

nostr:note152dryp2q2m058t7wn7ymev9suladah30qezpq00jt03s622uyw6qu4g79w