Exactly. Why not just build on and enhance Nostr?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

β€œwhy not enhance the fediverse?”

- fediverse people on nostr

Fedi is inherently broken.

What is to say Nostr isn’t?

Because Nostr is still very early and now's the time to enhance, build, or change it. ActivityPub is from 2016 and much more set in the ways on how to accomplish tasks and features - it's more mature. Nostr is more malleable.

Nostr is not that malleable.

It was also a poor name choice

SMTP, POP3, FTP, HTTP, TCP, IP, UDP, all have the best names.

πŸ₯΅

I loved POP3 tbh

I like the idea of DHT getting around the need for DNS. At least if I understand what proponents of the system have said on nostr, but having not read the docs, I can't really speak on it.

My loose understanding is that some of this is already being worked on with Nostr by several people.

I thought so too, but I had lost track of the project.

You analyzed it correctly. Makes every npub a censorship-resistant dns so you can own a piece of the internet.

Where nostr is 6 nodes #pubky is 6 million.

The two systems can work together but pubky is working now. Nostr could integrate it. It might take a day, it might take a year, but it wont take 10 years.

Users get 10x or 100x more options. So some are adopting early.

It'll take days, once someone takes on the task. It's an impressively simple solution 😏

A Free as in freedom alternative to DNS is as worthy for development as the relay itself.

There's nothing inherently wrong with creating a competing protocol, if their core concept is different. We're not obligated to use it, or anything, and we should be open to someone outside of our Nostrverse having a good idea. We're not the only clever people on the planet.

But, I'm not really sure why this bubbled up, to be honest. I just saw Melvin talking about it and everyone got all excited for no reason. I've been looking into it and πŸ€·πŸ»β€β™€οΈ whatever.

Astroturf marketing.

Wow, just tried to tag Melvin and there's dozens of imposter accounts, geez.

Nostr.band is a hot mess, fr.