If you know they’re Iranian, yep! That’s the law.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

you can't be reasonably held accountable for knowing that based on an lnurl

Yes you can, that’s the law

its not, actually. the law is about knowingly doin businesses. read it. read the cases. this is a made up fear

Not all crimes require the gov’t to prove intent.

You mean those crimes where the government is the criminal and trying to lock you in for it?

It's not about intent, it's about knowledge

If I zap somebody 2 cents for a post, and there's no reasonable way for me to know where they are from, and no reasonable expectation that my 2 cents matters

I will happily break that law and happily win in court

In the case of companies that are doing large amounts of transactional business with repeat customers

and have access to their IP addresses and have reasonable knowledge of where they're from

those are the ones that get fined

In fact if you look at the web page around the sanctions you can see that that there's a lot of language around this

it has to be a significant amount of business and it has to be where you know who you're doing business with or your required to know who your business is with

not all transactions require full KYC

there are transactional limits

and obviously if you're shipping

https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/financial-sanctions/sanctions-programs-and-country-information/iran-sanctions

If you’re running an lnurl server you know the ip. Thus you at a minimum have to make a best effort here

oh I would agree for that

I just don't think random zaps on nostr matter

No, not everyone has to care about what US authorities say.

And aside from that, it has no moral or ethical authority. These sanctions are implemented only to mollify rich US Jewish groups (AIPAC), to punish political enemies, for economic hegemony (nordstream demolition), etc. ad nauseam.

It’s all 100% bullshit.