Replying to Avatar Nathan Day

I'm confused on Amethyst and pictures.

Can everyone see them now or just Amethyst users?

nostr:nevent1qqsqlps6rs8wjkds298a3e7cpxk7tlpcajqsfwjh7fx94uztsleapgczyrz0tea8t2xwx6pa22w07p3kssuu2209ys7xkyjm56rcjxvg2m9vwqcyqqqqgfcv0ajxp

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Can see pics on webclients, Amethyst and Plebstr. But Damus is the only one I don't have access to. I think the recent Amethyst update fixed this, but not 100% sure. Anyone?

Remember when noone else could use private zaps because only Damus had them (not part of the nip)? It happens when the Protocol is changing. Good ideas will stay and become adopted, bad ideas will go. I will steal the meme tho.

Growing pains. A big difference is that with this issue users can’t see these images. At least with zaps people still got the sats in their wallet even if it didn’t display consistently in clients. In this case, images displaying consistently in clients is the most important thing for users.

Please do not discuss this with me, because I do agree with that part. All I'm saying is, if concensus would be that it's a good idea and all clients support it, it would be fine for everyone. If the majority thinks it's not, Amethyst might need to change it back. The nip is being discussed for some months, and now that clients start to apply it, others go full on blocking it. That's the thing with different dev teams, but also that's what nips are for. An additional issue with this particular one is that it's not unambiguous how it should be used. I still think that this will be resolved one way or another in the next days/weeks.

Why did you reply and bring it up if you didn’t want to discuss it? πŸ€·β€β™‚οΈ

I just wanted to point out, lots of things are being developed and best ideas will stay. And I do agree that it's unfortunate for essentials like images that consensus seems not being given rn.

Agree with you on the part about it being an unfortunate situation. πŸ€™

Adding new features and changing well established features are just not the same thing

I see your note like this on Iris

This nostr:nevent

Oh.

So I guess external upload service until NIP-94 is more widespread then.

Would be cool to be able to select the upload service you wanted so Amethyst users could opt in/out of the NIP-94 for now nostr:npub1gcxzte5zlkncx26j68ez60fzkvtkm9e0vrwdcvsjakxf9mu9qewqlfnj5z.

I will make an option soon so that i can send nip 95 to the Play store.

The Play store?

Google store.. none of the nip 94 and 95 features are available to the masses yet.

This is what I’m seeing. Assuming there was supposed to be an image there?

Yep, Damus has to implement an NIP-94 url preview if they want you to see it.

This is not a NIPtatorship.

Or a NIPcensorship, depending on your point of reference.

Too bad there’s no possible way to come to NIPcensus on UX issues that affect every user in one way or another.

I’m good

what a good user experience we're building here!

We're learning for sure. Small percentage of Amethyst users are on the daily builds I think. Happy to be at the bleeding edge. πŸ€™

Thankfully it's just going to be a small subset of users. πŸ«‚

Options on latest built are πŸ”₯.

Ah, understood. ✌️

Can see it, although I am a F-Droid Amethyst user πŸ˜‰

Can't see, and I'm on#[3]

this is what i see on snort.

such a good user experience. πŸ˜†

https://void.cat/d/E33hixGZUqJbw6aSj5WEtc.webp