Why current polls on #Nostr are just moneygrabs:

Recently, the function of making a poll got added on Nostr.

To vote in a poll one has to #zap sats on a certain option to participate and only those that did that will see the results. The results are that the poll option that received the most sats get to be the highest ranked answer.

If someone desires a certain outcome, the only thing that person has to do is zap a relative high amount of sats to one answer of the poll and there it determines the outcome.

So, the data generated by those polls is spurrious, it says nothing about the public opinion as it is easely manipulated.

That leaves the question of what the goal really is to post such a poll and why they exist in this way in the first place?

The person that posts such a poll will receive all the sats that are zapped within that poll. And there is their incentive to post such a poll, they don't care about the outcome, they just want your #Bitcoin . Or in other words, a moneygrab.

Where is the world do You have a poll where You have to pay to participate? Usually people either participate for free in polls or they even get conpensation for the effort to participate. Would those people that post current polls on Nostr be still posting them if it would cost them sats? Off course not!

You all know who they are;

Save your sats, they're rare and will become more valuable over time! 😉

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

The intention in there somewhere was to avoid having bots swarming the polls to influence it. The result is that you just need more sats to steal the vote.

It’s not an easy problem to solve. How to run a vote (poll) in an anonymous protocol keeping it fair and balanced? Limiting to one vote per npub does not stop the bots.

Maybe if the poll poster could specify the price of voting (thus excluding anyone who cannot or does not want to afford it). Then every voter only has the option of zapping that amount, one vote per npub.

It might be well intended, but clearly the current way isn't working.

Some will make the argument of developing new features and testing it.

Ok, it's tested this way, it isn't working, remove the function and send everyone, that spent sats on these polls, their sats back. They can find them at their notification button.

I'm challenging them to do this.

With decentralized development, who is them? NIPs do not have to be supported by all clients.

Them is who that have posted these kind of polls.

You’d want them to refund people who zapped their polls? Personal responsibility on the side of the plebs zapping polls I’d say. Something exists, my choice to participate or not.

My point is, as I wrote in my original post, that it's only used as a moneygrab. By giving those sats back to the participants, they have an option to disprove my argument. 😉

If those poles had a real impact in nostr socity it would be a live example of #plutocracy

Pardon my spelling, polls I meant