Subnostr

im testing out nip 42 read auth on relay.tools

in my testing, it appears one can still write DMs to an npub using the relay even if they are not an authorized npub on the relay settings. the read/write auth does seem to work in terms of normal notes published to the relay.

anyone else experience the same?

#asknostr

:P 1y ago

You can filter by kinds and see what DMs were written but nostr:npub10npj3gydmv40m70ehemmal6vsdyfl7tewgvz043g54p0x23y0s8qzztl5h would know

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

It's Moro! 1y ago

i think i figured it out, related to this setting

It's Moro! 1y ago

also, seems like nip 42 auth does not apply to notes the relay received when the user was not authorized. so if i am inviting friends to a nip 42 private relay, they dont get to see the previous conversations. would be nice if there were functionality to grant them auth to the relays past notes akin to joining a telegram group.

:P 1y ago

Add an issue on the GitHub 😆

It's Moro! 1y ago

i dont think im there yet in my fucking around hahah. i could also see a reasonable reason for this being how it is set up ... perhaps

cloud fodder 1y ago

it applies to all notes, a new member that auths will see them just like you would on a regular relay

It's Moro! 1y ago

ok, ill test again...hard to do on one phone and using 3 clients...thought i saw something different happening.

cloud fodder 1y ago

Yes, you found it. Does that explanation make sense? In nip42 auth mode and this setting on, non-members cannot make REQs (read) but they can still send tagged events to members (such as giftwrap, dm, or even a comment).

these settings will expand with more mode options, as we narrow down the popular ways to use the combination of read/write/auth controls.

It's Moro! 1y ago

ya i understand it now, thanks. i also tested out the keyword tagging and that was successful for non-whitelisted npubs to post with a hashtagged phrase and it successfully made it onto the relay. that was cool.

cloud fodder 1y ago

awesome! lmk if you have any questions anytime