Replying to Avatar zappr (old key)

### zappr (cycle #169)

made by #[53]

### zapped users

**Please avoid replying to this post and tag me instead to not spam people with notifications.**

⚡️ Zapped #[0] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[1] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[2] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[3] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[4] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[5] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[6] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[7] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[8] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[9] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[10] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[11] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[12] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[13] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[14] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[15] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[16] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[17] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[18] 51 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[19] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[20] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[21] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[22] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[23] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[24] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[25] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[26] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[27] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[28] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[29] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[30] 44 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[31] 30 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[32] 30 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[33] 30 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[34] 30 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[35] 30 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[36] 30 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[37] 30 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[38] 30 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[39] 30 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[40] 30 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[41] 30 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[42] 35 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[43] 35 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[44] 23 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[45] 23 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[46] 23 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[47] 23 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[48] 23 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[49] 23 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[50] 23 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[51] 23 sats

⚡️ Zapped #[52] 14 sats

Total: 2146 sats

### zap pool stats

depth: 0 pubkeys

balance: 245770 sat

Please donate to keep the zaps flowing, 6k sat provides 125 people with zaps for 1 hour: zappr@semisol.dev

Donate to me for making the bot (will **not** be distributed): sats@semisol.dev

It seems that every client except Gossip still wrongly manage the notifications, flooding the user when a large thread starts:

Ex. in #[7] I was just mentioned (I didn't replied) and I'm receiving notifications for every reply because they include *all* the mentioned users in the first note as p-tag [*]

Proposal: why don't show only the notifications that are a direct reply to the user's note or are in his gerarchy (reply of reply)?

Or at least separate and giving them a different highlight related to their importance.

To notify direct replies (or the gerarchy) a client can use as reference the e-tag's npub instead of the p-tags.

[*] I suspect that the notification problem starts from the event structure, NIP-10 stated:

> When replying to a text event E the reply event's "p" tags should contain all of E's "p" tags as well as the "pubkey" of the event being replied to.

So p tags are accumulating at every reply, why is this necessary?

/cc #[1] #[0] #[5] #[2] #[3] #[6] #[4]

(This way we can test the issue realtime 🤣)

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Um, gossip isn't doing this "right" either. Someone should tell that gossip guy... oh wait, that's me. Gossip doesn't really have well designed notifications yet (because it doesn't track which posts you have read yet), and it includes the same long chain of replies in your 'inbox' as the other clients do.

Really?! :)

But my inbox in Gossip is clean, without the not-related replies that I see in other clients. Magic?

Oh... there is a setting "direct replies only". I forgot about that. I turn it off.

Hahahaha, this is the way!

Why you turn it off?

(Turned off just to test and quickly reverted)

Mark the issue

Never thought about this but it should be easy to identify whether the list of tagged events belongs to the user or not by looking into the DB, I'll think about this thanks for heads-up!