Question for you: Should a person be locked up forever for hitting and killing someone? (by accident of course) #AskNostr #Plebchain

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Accident? No. Intention is a big part of the spirit of the law. Now if they accidentally kill like 3 people in a row that's different

Agreed

It’s hard to say without specific situation

It is less productive to remove two people from the economy than one. The hitter should he indentured to the hittee's beneficiaries but continue to work.

Yes, but with some assessment as to whether it will happen again and after some jail time, for sure.

I agree. Reckless behavior must be punished. Population decline in western countries will change the calculus on productivity affect on justice system.

If there is no criminal intent: no.