Thinking catalytic carbon for whole home water filtration, anyone out there have strong opinions?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Have you done a water test? That is really the first step.

Carbon is good for neutralizing odor. It really depends on your water quality.

Reverse osmosis is the way to go as long as you have good water pressure. Carbon won't remove everything.

Doesn't this filter all the minerals aswell?

Yes if you use RO you then want to re-mineralize the water. Most RO systems are set up to do that.

Need to test first. Well or City?

Make sure test includes Deuterium.

I've been looking into options too and if you find something good please post. I'm in the market.

I have RO. Removes everything that carbon won’t like fluoride. For drinking water though you want to add back minerals in some way. Most kits come with a remineralizing filter.

Brita filter ftw

I think it can be great and effective, but efficacy depends on what you’re trying to filter out?

RO to remove hormones and pesticides

Maybe for whole house, but I'd still use RO for drinking/cooking water

Reverse osmosis then remineralization

Also, I found this site useful to see what's in my local supply and which methods can remove it.

https://www.ewg.org/tapwater/system.php?pws=CA1910156

lastly, ended up buying an inexpensive RO system from these folks www.freedrinkingwater.com . Spammy sounding domain, but good company.

Test first. Depending on the results, and what you are tying to filter out, there are several options.

Also consider water hardness.

Also consider whether your water only be filtered for the house, or will also be used in the garden/landscaping.

I use this for whole house

https://www.purewaterproducts.com/products/fm105

Mainly for showers, brushing teeth. I use a few 2.5” x 9.75” cartridges under sink for cooking and coffee but filters cannot beat fresh spring water, so I have spring water delivered for drinking.

My girlfriend had allergic reaction to water from expensive water filtering system that was softening the water.

Interesting podcast I just listened to on water!

https://pca.st/episode/08143f0e-97bc-40af-9add-71e480ec6489

Berkey (carbon) with the additional flouride/arsenic filters is my go-to.

I have a whole home filtration system and it certainly reduces water pressure throughout the home, keep this in mind.