Replying to Avatar WilliamHodl

Thinking about buying a hardware wallet to keep your precious Bitcoin safe?

Well, I bought 3 different hardware devices, and i'm going to go over some of the differences as well as pros/cons.

The 3 hardware devices i purchased were; Ledger, Trezor,Jade

I bought these 3, as they seem to be the most common,renown, and trusted. But there is tons more out there, I recommend doing your research and finding something that suits your needs and budget!

The 3 areas I will be going over with each device is, Security, User Friendliness,Aesthetic Appeal.

(Ledger Nano S)

For Security I will give this one a 5/5, I may not give the same ranking on some of Ledger's newer devices as there are concerns in the community that the Seed Phrase can be extracted from the secure element. All though it is also mentioned this is a service (A service where multiple 3rd parties hold your phrase and you can reaccess your crypto with KYC) that needs to be opted in to. The Ledger Nano S does not have the capability to do this.

For User Friendliness i give this one a 4/5, Setting it up and recovering was quite easy with this device, the display could be slightly larger, lucky for me i have good glasses!

For Aesthetic appeal I give this one a 4/5, solid design and looks inconspicuous like a standard USB drive.

(Trezor Model One)

For Security i will give this one a 4/5 as i have watched videos and read on forums on how the seed phrase can be extracted from the device, all through the device would have to be in possession of the attacker which means your seed phrase should still be safe from online attackers.

For User Friendliness i will give this one a 2/5, as i found it extremely difficult to recover with my seed phrase. You have to use the display on the hardware device, but then press scrambled buttons on your computer monitor to enter your seed phrase. The whole thing is weird and confusing to explain.

For Aesthetic appeal I give this one a 3/5, can't really embelish on this.

(Blockstream Jade)

For security I give this one a 4/5, as I do not like cameras built in, I put tape over it immediately. It's for another method of recovering your phrase, but I also don't like the idea of drawing a QR code, let alone relying on a QR Code, i much prefer the traditional , write your 24 words down method.

For User Friendliness i give this one a 5/5 , it was so fast to set up and recover that i barely remember the process.

For Aesthetic Appeal i give this one a 4/5, i feel this is because i didn't get one of the see through ones because they were sold out, but had i got one, it would of probably got a 5/5

________________

I hope you all liked my review, please leave in the comments your opinion, or let me know of a hardware device you really enjoy!

#bitcoin #plebchain #grownostr #ledger #trezor #Jade

I did use Trezor One and Ledger S for a long time, personally I find the Trezor slightly more user friendly and I like the U2F without unlocking (like a Yubikey) and without an app to install. However both are not so great regarding multisign as you cannot properly check what you sre signing and where the change is going.

And big con for Ledger, it's not fully open source.

I also had a KeepKey, but it's a kind of clone of Trezor with less function and somewhat buggy on Linux.

Then I did a Specter DIY, I guess it's similsr to Jade, it's not storing keys, just signing with keys you give to it temporarly. So you need to store the seed in plain on a paper/metal plate in 12/24 words or in QR, possibly you can store it in plain on a uSD card, but I'm really not a fan of this. Beside that it's one of the more advanced Bitcoin signing device I tested, if you want to learn or do advance setup without zero third party trust, that's a must have.

Finally I got a BitBox2 Bitcoin only. For me it's the one I'm recommanding as the most secure and user friendly, even if I'm not a fan of the touch capacitive buttons on the sides of it.

Next I want to test is the Coldcard4. It looks like the merge of Specter advance festures and Bitbox2 user friendliness with the most advanced security. But I will tell it when I got one. Probably with a long awaited blog post.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

No replies yet.