Thinking about buying a hardware wallet to keep your precious Bitcoin safe?

Well, I bought 3 different hardware devices, and i'm going to go over some of the differences as well as pros/cons.

The 3 hardware devices i purchased were; Ledger, Trezor,Jade

I bought these 3, as they seem to be the most common,renown, and trusted. But there is tons more out there, I recommend doing your research and finding something that suits your needs and budget!

The 3 areas I will be going over with each device is, Security, User Friendliness,Aesthetic Appeal.

(Ledger Nano S)

For Security I will give this one a 5/5, I may not give the same ranking on some of Ledger's newer devices as there are concerns in the community that the Seed Phrase can be extracted from the secure element. All though it is also mentioned this is a service (A service where multiple 3rd parties hold your phrase and you can reaccess your crypto with KYC) that needs to be opted in to. The Ledger Nano S does not have the capability to do this.

For User Friendliness i give this one a 4/5, Setting it up and recovering was quite easy with this device, the display could be slightly larger, lucky for me i have good glasses!

For Aesthetic appeal I give this one a 4/5, solid design and looks inconspicuous like a standard USB drive.

(Trezor Model One)

For Security i will give this one a 4/5 as i have watched videos and read on forums on how the seed phrase can be extracted from the device, all through the device would have to be in possession of the attacker which means your seed phrase should still be safe from online attackers.

For User Friendliness i will give this one a 2/5, as i found it extremely difficult to recover with my seed phrase. You have to use the display on the hardware device, but then press scrambled buttons on your computer monitor to enter your seed phrase. The whole thing is weird and confusing to explain.

For Aesthetic appeal I give this one a 3/5, can't really embelish on this.

(Blockstream Jade)

For security I give this one a 4/5, as I do not like cameras built in, I put tape over it immediately. It's for another method of recovering your phrase, but I also don't like the idea of drawing a QR code, let alone relying on a QR Code, i much prefer the traditional , write your 24 words down method.

For User Friendliness i give this one a 5/5 , it was so fast to set up and recover that i barely remember the process.

For Aesthetic Appeal i give this one a 4/5, i feel this is because i didn't get one of the see through ones because they were sold out, but had i got one, it would of probably got a 5/5

________________

I hope you all liked my review, please leave in the comments your opinion, or let me know of a hardware device you really enjoy!

#bitcoin #plebchain #grownostr #ledger #trezor #Jade

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

THIS IS FANTASTIC. Thank you. Keep sharing as cold storage is a scary thing for some and people need education. And comforting words.

And a warm blanket sometimes. And ice cream.

I just bought ledger nano x before the news. Is it still safe to use it while searching my next option.

Somehow it feels hard to believe ledger rug pulls in the near future?

I think people are over worrying. I feel as long as you don't opt into the 3rd party key custody feature. Your good. But another good option is to keep your corn on MULTIPLE hardware devices, all with separate wallets.

Thanks! I guess I have been worrying bit too much too✊

I was excited it was my first cold storage and only had nexo before. Set up device at home and to be honest I was so stoked reading instructions. “Check that there is no one in your house, device makes seed no one else but you sees it and you are your own bank” transfer my btc -> ledger, add chain to it and wear it for fun at home “now i am my own bank, proud”

Go to twitter maybe week later, “just send photo of your passport and you’ll never lost your seed”

Wait, what did I read a week ago and what i am reading now doesn’t quite match 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Was pretty mad really🤦‍♂️

Thinking of getting coldcard for my next option 💕

I like the jade the most. Really unbeatable value 💪

I wish I had waited, the clear orange one is beautiful

Wait what? Clear orange? 👀👀

I seen an ad that they have all different colors now.

Holy cow 🐮

nostr:note1f5v80mefmm5n62lacdp7ftymh4rytgrthw2uya9xvwze6z2es79ssxnz00

Ledger has withdrawn their support for an older device. If anyone had stored their keys on that device, the only way to retrieve them is by ledger's help.

Ledger has a crap history of protecting their user's personal details. So everyone who ordered devices from them (before the incident) to their home address, they all got doxxed.

I wouldn't use a Ledger even if you pay me, same goes for Trezor.

Actually, for the time being, I will ONLY use a Coldcard.

Till news comes out about them. The best method is not to trust a central point. As in don't Fanboy over one company. Use 3 different devices. Less chances of loosing your whole stack. No single company or central point of authority can be trusted. We have learned this time and time again.

No thanks, I already used Ledger and Trezor before, never again.

Now that you have hardware consider multisig with unchained. casa (if btc only isn't an issue for you).

Also why would someone only store there keys on there device and not paper also.

Correct but the issue still stands that they withdrew support of one of their devices.

Wow so helpful!

Cold card is probably the gold standard.

It's been around for 4 years. But OK lol.

If #Bitcoin only is important to you then working with bitcoin only companies should be too.

If you shitcoin; ledger and Trezor work fine.

I did use Trezor One and Ledger S for a long time, personally I find the Trezor slightly more user friendly and I like the U2F without unlocking (like a Yubikey) and without an app to install. However both are not so great regarding multisign as you cannot properly check what you sre signing and where the change is going.

And big con for Ledger, it's not fully open source.

I also had a KeepKey, but it's a kind of clone of Trezor with less function and somewhat buggy on Linux.

Then I did a Specter DIY, I guess it's similsr to Jade, it's not storing keys, just signing with keys you give to it temporarly. So you need to store the seed in plain on a paper/metal plate in 12/24 words or in QR, possibly you can store it in plain on a uSD card, but I'm really not a fan of this. Beside that it's one of the more advanced Bitcoin signing device I tested, if you want to learn or do advance setup without zero third party trust, that's a must have.

Finally I got a BitBox2 Bitcoin only. For me it's the one I'm recommanding as the most secure and user friendly, even if I'm not a fan of the touch capacitive buttons on the sides of it.

Next I want to test is the Coldcard4. It looks like the merge of Specter advance festures and Bitbox2 user friendliness with the most advanced security. But I will tell it when I got one. Probably with a long awaited blog post.

Thanks for this review! It was very helpful! I’ve been going back and forth between getting Jade or #Trezor… I think I’m starting to move away from Trezor with every review I read… I just saw Jade has the colorful transparent devices. They are so cute!!! They only have a pre-order for October though…. So I’m sitting here wondering if I dare keep all my Bitcoin in a hot wallet until October just to get an orange #Jade. 😳 just a girl’s priorities, I guess………. Do I go smart or do I go pretty? 😂

Go smart, sooner it's off a hot wallet the better. And the better you will sleep

I’m curious… would you explain more about why you don’t like the camera feature? Is it just a privacy thing? Do you think they could get hacked into? But there’s no internet connection, right? #noob questions….

It has Bluetooth capability, I don't want to risk it is still on and can be controlled. Even if you turn your cellphone off , it's not really off.

Ooh… I see. So maybe a #ColdCard would be best? I just keep hearing it’s not as user friendly, but I’m willing to learn.

Cold card sounds superior, but I want something my family can easily use in the case I pass away.

Have you made up your mind on something yet?

I recommend having multiple devices. And splitting your stack up.