Hey elsat, I already tagged Will before I think its the same issue as before concerning mentioning and quoting tags handling, not sure tho.
Discussion
Ngl I thought about leaving nostr forever yesterday because the publishing of that piece was such a nightmare. I cried because if someone REALLY needs to say something on nostr I don’t want them to go through that.
Example: activist, journalist, whistleblower, political dissident, survivor
I was so confused why I couldn’t see it. Some people could see it and others couldn’t. I’m not blaming anyone and I’m not mad but it was frustrating.
If you faced any issue, feel free to tag me and YakiHonne and we will get most of your questions answered. Just a side note: if you see a flow in Nostr that is working with most of the client, there is a high chances that is following the specs and others didnt update accordingly just all. or you can just use the "post in a note" feature from the dashboard right 3 dots to just share your article within a note, rather than quoting it 
This is not your fault. Thanks for your patience. I am documenting and will ask devs look into it.
Yeah, exactly.
Thank you. Glad that I didn’t unplug the internet forever. 😂
If you're this early to Nostr you're half user, half tester 🫂😂
Lovely. 😐
I just want to post 😂
I've seen it get a lot better here in the last two years. Every little bug that gets eyes on it helps. You've brought a lot of attention to the issue and your article. Double win in the end!
Your notes are appreciated BTW, keep posting.
More Carl, plz 😸
nostr:npub1yye4qu6qrgcsejghnl36wl5kvecsel0kxr0ass8ewtqc8gjykxkssdhmd0
Can you tell me what exactly happened immediately after hitting publish?
For example, did you receive some notification or feedback element from Yakihonne “article was published successfully”
Were you able or not able to immediately see the article in its’ published form?
What else happened?
What did you expect to happen that didn’t happen?
I hit publish and went to Damus to see if it was there. It wasn’t. I grabbed links from primal and tried to post it. The posts weren’t showing up for people. I’ll link below what people saw.
I spent 10 minutes trying to log on to habla.news. Couldn’t get in because there was nowhere to put my nsec.
Lost my mind and the community found it on most clients except for Damus. I posted it again. Same problem.
nostr:note1n39eahdch94aehmdserg638ugwq0fl6ju5nj6hx7vv2zfvtymvksh6gck0
I will share with you the process for publishing long form content and how you can check if your content is published properly 🙏
I believe you shared this note from damus, and damus uses note1 for long-form notes mentioning rather than its format naddr I found this issue before also.
nostr:npub1zafcms4xya5ap9zr7xxr0jlrtrattwlesytn2s42030lzu0dwlzqpd26k5 perhaps you could note this also, if you take the note1 from the content and tried to fetch it you will get the kind-30023 event
Yeah good point. In the event json Eliza shared I see noteID.
nostr:npub1yye4qu6qrgcsejghnl36wl5kvecsel0kxr0ass8ewtqc8gjykxkssdhmd0 do you remember from which app and where exactly you copied the noteID in the note screenshoted below (“Is everyone able to open this article…”)
I’m not sure, I’m sorry I was grabbing from everywhere. I even posted the QR code. I was just trying to do whatever to see if it would work.
Look at this craziness 😂 click the link.
This one seems correct
That’s how it looks when I click the link.
It is naddr in the event. However, it still does not load in damus.
The thing that tripped me out was that I had written other pieces posted the exact same way and they had shown up. That’s part of why I freaked out.
I think the best solution is to write and share in one place, I' m uploading the video soon, then other clients can see what it is missing for them add adjust it. In addition, you can also directly copy paste the full link of the article (old school way) within the note
Here you go, if you didnt find it in YakiHonne and njumb.me it won't exist in any other place, if you found it it means other clients that you seek your content to be visible in have an issue with it.
fyr nostr:npub1zafcms4xya5ap9zr7xxr0jlrtrattwlesytn2s42030lzu0dwlzqpd26k5
https://video.nostr.build/54f2b63d41f1c90d875c1ae57cda074e9ea9d5e3eb7672b4418463cdabf1d9c4.mp4
Thanks, I can see the new article you published.
The outstanding question how did the unhappy path earlier described take place.
I think 2 parts are crucial actually 2.5:
- the `root issue that i mentioned earlier, when the content is not short notes.
- Damus (maybe others not sure) assume the mentionned content is a shot note thats why we can see the note1, however due it is clearly not kind-1, so wrong encoding in here, perhaps the quoting triggered it.
- the .5 part is that: some clients handle the mentions while others handle quotes exclusively and not both.
Thats why I suggested nostr:npub1yye4qu6qrgcsejghnl36wl5kvecsel0kxr0ass8ewtqc8gjykxkssdhmd0 to minimize the actions to one client, and we see how we notify others to fix such things.
nostr:npub1yye4qu6qrgcsejghnl36wl5kvecsel0kxr0ass8ewtqc8gjykxkssdhmd0 when you published your article in yakihonne, and then checked your profile feed in damus did you see the article in your own feed?
Example article I just posted screenshotted below
No I didn’t see it on Damus at all.
Hm. Any idea what that might be nostr:npub13v47pg9dxjq96an8jfev9znhm0k7ntwtlh9y335paj9kyjsjpznqzzl3l8 ?
nostr:npub1yye4qu6qrgcsejghnl36wl5kvecsel0kxr0ass8ewtqc8gjykxkssdhmd0 can you try lowering your relay count to 12 from over 30, and publishing a new article using yakihonne?
Yup!
Done. Published.
I see the article in damus, maybe it’s because of this? I haven’t pushed the hotfix to the appstore yet but i’m doing that today
It doesn’t show on my Damus for me currently.
Ok looks like that was the issue. Will try to get the hotfix out today
I broadcasted it just to be sure. So you can try clicking the naddr again to see if that fixed it. If you could go to your settings and copy the version number to here that will also help clarify things.
If none of this worked its likely the regression i just found yesterday.
What’s the naddr? This comment is confusing to me.
The link in your post. When i click it, it shows your article (although we should show a preview for it). I also see it on your profile.
This is how my Damus profile looks to me right now. No article.
Can you copy your version to here? It’s in settings at the bottom. Also you have a very large number of relays (27), i would target around 4-7. Not sure if thats a problem here but damus can get unstable when you have too many …
My Damus currently says that I have 14 relays. I deleted a bunch. Here is the same article posted today to try to help to see if the problem was fixed.
Here’s a link from the other day. Same article.
Is this not it?
That’s it. I can not see it on my Damus account currently. The community could half see it and half not see it. Different clients had it visible. It was a community effort to figure out what went wrong.
just need your version number so i can figure out whats wrong (in settings)
I don’t know what that means and I’m close to reaching my frustration limit because this has been a conversation for a few days. I’m trying to help but I’m about to shut down and go non verbal for a few weeks 😂
Understandable. No rush 😅
I published a new Harry Potter piece to hopefully cut down on the confusion. Just to differentiate the articles and hopefully make problem solving easier.
nostr:npub1xtscya34g58tk0z605fvr788k263gsu6cy9x0mhnm87echrgufzsevkk5s I can see the harry potter article from Eliza’s profile
I think you mean hard hitting journalism 🪄😂
We plan on making this automatic so you don’t have to manually set these, but for now damus strictly follows the list no matter what you set it to. This can cause congestion
I FOUND THE NADDR! 💅🏻
nostr:naddr1qqgrqdmx8ymxycekvcmx2efnxgmrzq3qyye4qu6qrgcsejghnl36wl5kvecsel0kxr0ass8ewtqc8gjykxksxpqqqp65wesehnx
The post that you are referencing was one of the first times that I posted it. I reposted it today and it’s not showing.
That specific note that you are referencing was me desperately trying whatever to see if it was live. I was just trying whatever.
and when u fetch the noteID you will find its a long-form content kind-3023, I saw this behaviour before in Damus
Check this note while on Damus. 😩
Looks like our NIP-23 notes (published via habla) also don't show up on nostr:nprofile1qqsraldwhvwcjgltmxwfu7kw8dqef2692yhzheuurd7k3kfy8cxjdqgpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumn0wd68ytnzv9hxgtcj76jgr any idea why nostr:nprofile1qqsr9cvzwc652r4m83d86ykplrnm9dg5gwdvzzn8ameanlvut35wy3gpzpmhxue69uhkummnw3ezuamfdejsz9thwden5te0wfjkccte9ekk7um5wgh8qatzqyt8wumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnswf5k6ctv9ehx2aq38qmrf?
Share neventID, naddr
nostr:naddr1qqqqz9thwden5te0dehhxarj9ehhsarj9ejx2a30qgsrp7uu0z6euaefqfw9f7ut270n2ag33rtyehw0k2gaxud7ru0rcwsrqsqqqa28kkaj8m
nostr:naddr1qqxnzde5xgmrgv3e8yurzvpkqy2hwumn8ghj7mn0wd68ytn00p68ytnyv4mz7q3qxraec794nemjjqju2nack4ulx463rzxkfnwulv536dcmu8c78saqxpqqqp65wua507t
nostr:naddr1qqxnzde5xgmnvvf3xsurxvpcqy2hwumn8ghj7mn0wd68ytn00p68ytnyv4mz7q3qxraec794nemjjqju2nack4ulx463rzxkfnwulv536dcmu8c78saqxpqqqp65w73wkxk
Can you post your app version (its in settings at the bottom)
1.13.1
hrm I see them on your account. weird
When I open the profile on Damus I can only see the original introduction post. The long form posts do not appear. Also in my feed I can't see them even if I follow the hashtag etc. Only thing that works for me is searching manually via note id then the note shows up.
That's how it looks for me.
Hm I could not recreate. My steps:
1) Created keys in damus
2) Keys in nos2x
3) published article in habla
The only thing i can think of is the change made to the profile query ( nostr:npub1yaul8k059377u9lsu67de7y637w4jtgeuwcmh5n7788l6xnlnrgs3tvjmf conversation feature) must be tripping up some relays?
I need to look at how the query changed and how it might be affecting it
It’s possible I broke something with that change but don’t have time to look into it yet.
Ok ngl if it’s a whole tech lesson with stuff that I don’t understand I’m not going to learn it on my own. It needs to be drawn in crayon for me. 😂
It shouldn’t be this difficult. Let’s see what team dev nostr can do to smooth out the process 💪
Thank you all for being so kind. It’s really sweet. If it makes you feel any better it did get a ton of eyes on it and that’s crazy because it’s so freaking long. Hopefully it helps someone.
Added issue placeholder here in case it is caused by poor interop:
nostr:npub14ya7n7czu3kyq3m2sn6kjawmtq6ll6kerrlm90gz9yzfjmflmsxq8dsn39 I dont see this tag. Can you share the neventID ?
Here you go
Ah yes, this one is a known bug. I dont think this is what is going on with the unfindable naddr reported and shared by Eliza and her readers.