Unlimited supply. Which is the opposite of the whole point of money, scarcity, fixed supply. I would add that, the brilliance of bitcoin is that it achieved the optimum between all tradeoffs of the critical variables, to become immutable, incorruptible money. That’s why there will never be a second best.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Scarcity and fixed supply aren't the same. But agree that bitcoin will get this point for finite supply at the characteristics that make a good money. But one could argue monero has a better fungibility because of the better privacy.

Fixed supply is a form of scarcity, the absolute form…re your second point, it‘s a trade-off that ultimately negatively impacts Bitcoin‘s immutability. Bitcoin optimally solves for one human problem only, money. One has to be careful not to superimpose trying to solve unrelated issues on it, that dilutes the purity. It’s like saying we are limiting free speech to solve child pornography….Bitcoin has enough privacy for two peers to transparently transact with each other, they have to trust each other. The invasion of privacy by a third party is unacceptable and has to be solved directly.

Ok true, absolute scarcity is a fixed supply. But a private transaction is really hard because of the on-chain transparency. If we do a transaction with a change output included I always have to take care of the future usage of this change output. If we do a cash transaction where I get some money back you can't see what I do with the change.

It's a fallacy that absolute scarcity alone automatically = more valuable

You can fix the supply, but you can't control demand. Ultimately value is subjective like any good bitcoin maxi austrian should know. And demand can change at any time.

On-chain Bitcoin has some anonymity if done correctly, but can never have privacy. Big difference between the two. It's a transparent public ledger.

https://github.com/libbitcoin/libbitcoin-system/wiki/Scarcity-Fallacy

This fixed supply scarcity crap is gonna be the reason the next generation is gonna make their own coin just like btc did in the first place. You're not helping anyone but yourselfs. Bitcoin is not even usable due to lack of any privacy features.

nah.

infinite divided by 21M is a stupid meme.

as if the supply inflation of gold over the last 2k years made it a poor store of value.

these maxis need to get a grip and stop just repeating stupid saifedean catchphrases.

Why are people forgetting that a certain point in history btc holders got the same amount of coins as bch. That means there is a fuck load more than 21m coins right now.

My understanding is they converted/sold their bch for btc. No expansion of btc supply needed to do that.

What about all the other blockhains that exist? Some real deep thinkers here...