in fact: censorship was his feature request for primal 🤷♀️
Discussion
Only for CSAM afaik
censorship is a slippery slope. Other people want it only for anti-semitism, racism, transphobia
Csam is not free speech and whoever is hosting the images can get arrested, nostrbuild clarified yesterday this matter they take down the content same for primal and whoever offers the service should do the same. 
nostr:naddr1qq2hg46lfenycjnwvffrvn6l2ehyykryfskk7qgkwaehxw309aex2mrp0yhx6mmnw3ezuur4vghsygye39gqgylmw4kcgdu39npjhcrnpklphlrtt5hw7av7z3tvyw0eq5psgqqqw4rsaj0tdn
The law is a cop-out response. All we have to do is arrest people for anti-semitism and it will stop being free speech too. So long as your platform always conforms to the ideals of the state, it will never be a robust free speech platform.
I don't think this applies to Nostr though. Images were never a core part of the platform and I would be shocked if the USA ever gives a shit about text based CP, or if Nostr ever gets in trouble for allowing the unchecked distribution of text based notes.
Are you a pedophile?
I am! Do you want to take advantage of Nostr's fantastic censorship resistance in order to insult me to my face? It's been way too long since someone's told me to kill myself, let alone shared a more personal or thought out insult.
There is always the idea that you won't do a very good job though, so I understand if you would prefer to just mute me and pretend I'm not here.
Just include a swastika and the text note will be illegal in Germany.
Base64 images are very heavy most relays will filter as spam right away but anyone can run you own relay same with a blossom server, nostr still being censorship resistant but nobody is obligated to store anything on their relays/servers.
Nah, Blossom servers will never be censorship resistant until they can leverage Tor to keep the host server secret. Media restrictions on the clearnet are just too ubiquitous. But I don't think Nostr needs media to be Nostr! To me, Nostr has always been about notes, not media.
If I'm understanding correctly the final goal of blossom servers is to be censorship-resistant because they give the same hash so if it goes down the client can look for the same hash on other server and the server can be used over tor.
nostr:nevent1qqs8gl8t88hvc90xcgnw6qmsm7xnf73mcg72l8r54h54q7ydgf7v3hsqcdk57
In that case it seems like it would be on the client to initiate the connection through Tor. I can't imagine a world where such a client would ever connect with such a server by default, unless that server exclusively stores content that would be fine on the clearnet anyway.
Tor has been around for ages but I haven't seen a lot of interest from internet users. I was a regular visitor of one website that experienced deplatforming/web hosting issues and had to move to Tor for a period of time. During that period, I saw the number of users drop drastically. Nobody wanted to use Tor.
Maybe it would be different if it was automatically implemented in Nostr; maybe it would catch on if it was more convenient. But personally I don't see the appeal of pushing to integrate censorship resistant media with Nostr. If someone wants to browse loli content, people have already found a few clearnet web hosts who will tolerate it. And if they are looking for actual CSAM/child pornography, I'm sure there are still plenty of Tor users and .onion sites sites that the FBI will never be able to touch.
I don't want Nostr to drive away their users and piss off the FBI all so that they can provide a service that nobody wants or needs. I say leave Tor media servers for when we actually need them.
There is a big difference between using Tor to connect to clearnet servers and using Tor to connect to darknet servers. I would love to pass all my internet traffic through Tor. But that doesn't mean there are a lot of darknet only sites or services that I'd want to connect to.
I don't have a fundamental issue with censorship resistant web hosting. It's just that I'm not particularly interested in any of the content that actually needs it.
Sorry for starting my response before you finished editing. My settings page just tells me to install Orbot. Either way, this seems to be for regular relays on .onion domains, not Blossom servers.
Have you applied the latest update? It's been some time since internal Tor was integrated, and Blossom was rolled out yesterday. You can easily enable image loading on Tor by flipping the switch if necessary. It can be done by default to the same settings as the relays.
My old-ass phone is already crying about memory, and downloading the app from Github is still a pain, so I'm going to wait.
Seriously though, is there anything stopping someone from straight up uploading child porn? Will Amethyst users just be randomly downloading it by default?
It's not by default I said it can be done by default, servers can scam for csam like nostrbuild is doing and I don't think anyone will go to run their own server to upload such things.
What if the Blossom server doesn't give a shit about people uploading child pornography? I know that if I ran a Blossom server over Tor I probably wouldn't care what users decided to upload. Any user who enables Blossom over Tor would start seeing any child pornography any other user feels like uploading.
But seriously, besides the ability to host child pornography, what would a Blossom server even get out of operating over Tor?
The use for Tor is for political upheaval for example thinking about something like jan 6 but not being a psyop, people on civil war Myanmar that are even printing guns trying to overthrow the government or people being genocided in gaza are some examples. Jews use metadata to kill Palestinians if they had this is a matter of life and death.
nostr:nevent1qqsw0h9659gk0guupjq53668wndpejparu43yrrvsf5uzuly52pjrkguymhrm
nostr:nevent1qqsw5l2c6x8gyj72u4wqwypk5s608w36655msxgplmn873xclq2auwqs0uq8u
Now if you are fine hosting CSAM you are sick we would probably make a bounty to get your head, just saying 🤙🏻
I'm not interested in hosting anything actually, let alone using Tor. But please don't let that stop you. Put out a bounty for my head if you want. Or if that's too much effort, please just tell me if you believe there's something wrong with me. You have my attention and you're guarunteed to accomplish at least as much as anyone else has.
What is the use of Tor for SERVERS? When does a server need Tor? When does an image server need Tor? Are there any image servers today that need Tor?
There's no need for tor only backups on many different jurisdictions but in case of a whistle-blower a tor backup is something we can do here there are lots of media we can't assess without vpn already like Rumble and it's just normal content. So my point is blossom servers don't have to be on Tor it can just be on different jurisdictions. https://cdn.nostrcheck.me/091b78a2b576848796cc63c62f217e013f4af583a97b26d09ae79f00e17e5f80
if I would get a nickel for every time someone says „racism is not free speech“ …
I believe cartoons are legal in most countries. But you already got hordes of bullies who refer fully clothed anime girls with big titties a CP and demand censorship.
