Thinking about it more, laeserin was getting at a better explanation from the start

It's about bias

If forms are the system, it's biased in favor of devs who will fill out forms

Those are devs who have time to check if the form seems worth filling out, devs who feel comfy giving the form whatever info it asks for

I think if you're trying to bias your pool of devs in favor of the best ones you probably don't want to filter out the ones you're filtering out there

Why do you want a system biased in favor of devs who have time and trust these forms?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Yes, the form itself is a sort of test. What is it testing for?

The word "conform" contains the word "form", after all.

Obvious reasons.

someone has to do the discovery work. Either the fund does it (finds devs) or the developers do it (applies to the fund). There has to be a selection process somewhere. So either the devs can self-select or the fund can go searching through all Nostr projects on earth.

So it's about incentives. The fund isn't going to spend extra energy to ALSO give away money. Theyre already "spending" a ton. So the developers are incentivized to surface themselves up; to "spend" comparatively little (time) to make themselves known and potentially gain a lot.

The filtering and selection has to happen somewhere. "hey developer who wants free money, make yourself known to me by writing a little bit on this public form and I'll read all the submissions" is far lower friction and cheaper than "okay let me scour the whole fucking internet to find a place to lose a bunch of cash."

What's wrong with the fund going searching through all nostr projects on earth? They could keep them all in a spreadsheet or something. Keeping the list complete would be a great ongoing research project for an organization trying to be the central nervous system or nucleus of nostr

Another way of looking at it - why should any nostr project not be on a list of all nostr projects tracked by opensats? How is that not a good thing to have?

I made a list, with that idea in mind, a while back. Wanted to add a column "has received a grant".

https://wikifreedia.xyz/nostr-devs/npub1m4ny6hjqzepn4rxknuq94c2gpqzr29ufkkw7ttcxyak7v43n6vvsajc2jl