nostr:npub16qct6ge6zdr72yxrw2cc0rsqyp9j9qrjs9pkz3gkydc839jrtk5sj8al6e

I don’t know. In any case, IDF intervention in Hawara seems to have been response to the shooting. Plus there was another shooting, which Hamas admitted was done by its two members.

What I’m just trying to understand how did you come to a conclusion that 7 October massacre was organised overnight by Hamas and two shootings, one of which Hamas took responsibility for, constituted “violation of ceasefire by Israel”.

nostr:npub1j8m6n55er97404gz59f35yt7h22lqh9dk5algdxlnza90paca7hsk5v5r7 nostr:npub19f72q0s795zwdn5ca8vdl76kjdtvcm3eceagmg8tf97rtad6z00sv6hz40

i have to go for my lectures so here is a quick wrap up of our last discussion:

1. the shooting occur in tulkarm, not hawara. the cities are quite far apart. (1)

2. Even with regular perimeter standard post shooting, the surveillance perimeter doesnt make sense. apart from the fact that tulkarm was the major city, they only close a distant palestinian city, not the closer israelu ones.

3. IDF made inconsistent statement about their involvement. in the one as you mentioned above and in several other statements it said its army was the one who raids the huwara vity (2) while in others it said it was done by other parties (3)

4. I am actually searching for a statement from hamas saying the two gunmen whete theirs. mind sharing that? the news was widely circulated but the actual statement doesnt seemed to exist.

5. Hamas is the de facto government of gaza. having military preparedness is uncommon. even the USA has ever existing presence in china waters.

6. the 6th october incident was a tipping point. as you can see from (4) and (5) tere were numerous killing already occur in 2023, higher than the previous years. lookinh even further, the killing has always occurred beyond 15 years ago (6)

1.

2. https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/palestinian-killed-during-settler-assault-west-bank-town-palestinian-officials-2023-10-06/

3.

https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/reuters/palestinian-killed-during-settler-assault-on-west-bank-town/48867462

4. https://apnews.com/article/israel-palestinians-west-bank-settler-violence-gaza-war-68debe29dcc2f5a58bd899e1e424911c

5. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_Israeli%E2%80%93Palestinian_conflict_in_2023

6.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

nostr:npub16qct6ge6zdr72yxrw2cc0rsqyp9j9qrjs9pkz3gkydc839jrtk5sj8al6e

statement from hamas saying the two gunmen whete theirs

That was quoted in one of the articles. I don’t follow Hamas statements closely. I followed their Telegram channel for a while but it was similar to Russian military updates, with an endless stream of virtual victories, so I stopped.

Hamas is the de facto government of gaza.

Yes, since they took it with in armed conflict in 2007. This also means they bear 100% responsibility for the safety of civilians in Gaza. Except they directly denied that responsibility in the discussion of tunnels being reserved exclusively for Hamas members.

having military preparedness is uncommon.

Preparedness is one thing. A complex offensive operation that includes breaching guarded border and barrages of rockets fired from concealed launchers is completely different scale that requires careful planning and coordination. Can’t happen overnight.

nostr:npub1j8m6n55er97404gz59f35yt7h22lqh9dk5algdxlnza90paca7hsk5v5r7 nostr:npub19f72q0s795zwdn5ca8vdl76kjdtvcm3eceagmg8tf97rtad6z00sv6hz40

which statement? because i really cant find it

saying they gained dominance because of armed conflict is an understatement. please read on mecca agreement 2007.

complex offensive operation? you must be living in a country with no dominant neighbour. i for one living in a nation neighbouring singapore, who was trained by Israel, able to takeover my capital in theorically 6 hours and have in average excurse into our airspace 836 times per year (1). i.e what you called a complex operation is propagated. with that, i do not condone or agree or any attack let it be to israeli or palestinian civilians

reference.

(1)https://www.mstar.com.my/lokal/semasa/2011/06/20/jet-pejuang-singapura-ceroboh-malaysia-2508-kali---ahmad-zahid